Letterman took Phoenix to task for tricking him (he made the actor admit that he hadn’t been in on the joke or scripted) as well as using most of the footage in the film without paying The Late Show a licensing fee. He even (jokingly?) told Phoenix that he owed him $1 million. When Phoenix, playing along, asked if they could discuss it in private, Letterman took a hard swipe saying they could go to one of I’m Still Here’s
Really though, at this point, who’s to say what’s real anymore? Maybe Letterman wasn’t mad and this was all a hoax. Maybe I’m Still Here 2 will come out in a year and a half and we’ll learn that Phoenix and Letterman’s clean cut exteriors are all an act and backstage they’re actually drugged up messes. There are just so many questions! What’s real? What’s fake? And, most importantly, which one of these guys is the Devil in the elevator?!