1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough

Occupy Wall Street’s ‘Human Microphone’: Insanely Brilliant…Or Just Insane?

Video
» 55 comments

In a sea of people taking video with hand-held HD cams and accessing the web with their smartphones, the Occupy Wall Street movement has managed a surprisingly old-school, almost primal, atmosphere. Alongside the drumbeats, public urination, and fugitives from justice, the protesters–who, by law, cannot use any microphones, speakers, or bullhorns–have been forced to amplify the words of guest speakers by loudly repeating whatever they say. On Sunday, Slovenian philosopher Slavoj Zizek spoke to the masses, and the human microphone was in full effect:

It’s an instant joke-killer, as the monotone human microphone has some trouble with cadence and timing. Zizek’s story about the red ink, for instance, elicited some chuckles that seemed to be more out of respect than anything (the laughs came after the human microphone repeated the punchline, not when Zizek–clearly within earshot of the front line of video-takers and repeaters–first uttered the line). And Zizek hasn’t been the only one having to deal with the microphone’s quirks. Michael Moore dropped a couple quick jokes in his rallying cry, and they were wholly lost in translation:

Also, the human microphone seems to malfunction just a little bit when the speakers doing a mic check ask participants to repeat the “no drugs or alcohol” mantra:

NPR’s Richard Kim nailed the nuances of the human microphone, saying that it’s agonizingly slow, but still a pretty important part of the movement. It still has its kinks, however, including a speaker’s inability to make deep points.
 

The overall effect can be hypnotic, comic or exhilarating—often all at once…. The human mic is not so good for getting across complex points about, say, how the Federal Reserve’s practice of quantitative easing is inadequate to address the current shortage of global aggregate demand, so speakers tend to express their ideas in straightforward narrative or moral language.

 
As the Occupy [Your City Name here] movement moves across the country, there will surely be cities that have much more lax standards on actual microphones and bullhorns. But so far, in cities like, for instance, Atlanta, the human microphone seems to be sticking.

Videos of human microphone will eventually go viral when some speaker decides to toy with it and starts telling jokes, just for the sake of hearing them repeated by the lifeless voice–like the early text-to-speech computer programs. Until then, however, the human microphone will remain a widely-overlooked element of these protests: a necessary tool that still has a few bugs in the mainframe.

Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • The Real Royal Emperor

    This is immensely clever.

  • TruDat

    I’ll go with insane.

  • The Real Royal Emperor

    Demonstrably.

  • Anonymous

    It’s immensely fun to participate in as well.

  • Anonymous

    It’s not a “human microphone” thing, it’s a collectivist unity thing. 

    The anti-individual chants go on even where there is bullhorns, like OccupyPhilly where I live or in Georgia where the “democratic collective” wouldn’t allow John Lewis to speak.

    Silly white kids.

  • Anonymous

    Free food , condoms, clothes , bedrolls …drugs , alcohol and liberals .

    What more do you need ?

    They are fighting for their rights — to partay!The Occupy Wall Street protest has drawn an unwelcome crowd of freeloaders who joined the movement for the sex, drugs and free food — and they are blending right in.
    The opportunists — ranging from addicts in need of a meal to well-off teens looking to hook up — have in some cases taken up residence in the demonstrators’ makeshift village in Zuccotti Park, upsetting the movement’s organizers.“Most of the kids are trust-fund babies. They don’t need to be here,” said Andre, 40, an activist. “I’ve seen some making out, having sex. It doesn’t look good.”

    Read more: http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/manhattan/park_wreck_freeloaders_GyDZGW4tFXDRx0oNRycVvK#ixzz1aO6CmFAv

  • http://twitter.com/Good_Lt Good Lt.

    You know what’s an immensely clever protest maneuver?

    Crapping on a police car:

    http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2046586/Occupy-Wall-Street-Shocking-photos-protester-defecating-POLICE-CAR.html

    Stupid teabaggurz! Look at what you’re making the Obamacrat mobs do now!

  • TruDat

    The police car defecation is clear evidence of that liberal “intellect” the liberals are continually telling us about.

  • Anonymous

    So RRK, while we’re here. What is your take on the “occupy” attack on our nations air and space museum. As I remember you held the entire Tea Party to account for the action of one or a few people.

    So… do your standards hold true for the “Occupy” crowd?

    I know this is off topic. But as Mediaite had chosen not to cover this I’m just being curious.

  • TruDat

    Immensely clever if you’re an immense dullard.

  • Anonymous

    Robert stands with the ” whippersnappers and beatniks “, as he calls them ,whatever damage they cause ,  because they are lefties .

  • http://www.sarainitalyblog.blogspot.com/ sarainitaly

    I thought the two funniest things I’ve seen about the protests, and how they are conducted, are this headline:

    ‘Occupy Atlanta’ Silences Rep. John Lewis Via Jazz Hands

    http://townhall.com/tipsheet/guybenson/2011/10/09/video_occupy_atlanta_silences_rep_john_lewis_via_jazz_hands

    And this tweet and video:

    Hidden footage of the first #OccupyWallStreet meeting - 
    http://youtu.be/LQqq3e03EBQ

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_M5V6VTQAVLARF7XXO47Z5OCZWM TangledThorns

     These guys are OK but nothing compared to those storming the Smithsonian in DC last weekend.

    http://youtu.be/wc9OSFLnyUI

  • Anonymous

    Here’s part of the response: http://mediamatters.org/blog/201110100001

  • Anonymous

    The Real Royal Emperor

    A totally pointless, non-substantive post that does nothing to advance the national dialogue. Please, when you have nothing to offer, just don’t post.

  • Anonymous

    Priscilla Grim is the face of this movement. Go Grim!

    http://gothamist.com/

  • The Real Royal Emperor

    I was unimpressed with this. Often, demonstrators must show their concern for the law and their contempt for lawmakers by engaging in action not strictly legal. The lunch counter sit-ins, for example, were all illegal. And, the demonstrators engaging in illegal activity, even for good motives, have to be willing to take the consequences. When my commitment to the USN ended, I as very active in the Peace Movement. I was detained a couple of times. Tear-gassed a few times. But, I’m not sure that this incident rose to anything of that level. It was silly. Silly and illegal are toxic.

    I do think some dialogue on the use of drones is in order. This is powerful technology, and it can be very beneficial, but it can also be very dangerous. An educational demonstration would have been welcomed.

    I did not welcome this effort, and I found it ill-conceived, ill-executed and deeply troubling.

  • The Real Royal Emperor

    That was, indeed, disgusting.

  • The Real Royal Emperor

    I assume you didn’t mean funny in the traditional sense Americans use the word?

  • Anonymous

    Priscilla Grim is the face of this movement. Go Grim!

    http://gothamist.com/

  • Anonymous

    The Real Royal Emperor

    A totally pointless, non-substantive post that does nothing to advance the national dialogue. Please, when you have nothing to offer, just don’t post.

  • Anonymous

    Speaking of disgusting , Robert , rein in some of your characters like LLoyd C or the lot of you will get banned again .

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1497076194 Travis Pierson

    Serves a dual purpose – it carries the word to those outside of earshot and assists in the further brainwashing of the OWbots. I first saw it in the video of the obviously racist Atlanta protesters who wouldn’t allow Rep. Lewis to speak and I ended up with snotbubbles in my mustache.

  • Anonymous

    Robert and BFD get teargassed and arrested on a regular basis when things get rowdy at Ramrod’s All Male Revue .

    Robert likes BFD to get put in jail occasionally , then he knows BFD will at least get deloused .

  • http://twitter.com/IKIDYOUNOT Mis Chievous

    Only a double rainbow would make this more fun to watch.  #occupyreality

  • AliveStillKickin

    Why aren’t all of the lying liberal politicians and back-slappers down on Wall Street wallowing in the stink and filth they have created?
    Hypocrites!!

  • Nancillarypeloslinton

    How amazing that the ‘Occupy Wall Streeters and the Tea Partiers have some of the same grievances against Obama. When Rick Santelli and the Tea Partiers told Obama not to bail out greedy Wall Street and not to bail out the corrupt banking system who would have thought that so many in the country outside the Tea Party would agree. Sounds like Obama loses in a landslide.

    Herman Cain-2012!

  • Anonymous

    A right winger were responsible he was an assistant editor for the conservative The American Spectator. 

  • AliveStillKickin

     ”Movement”?….ROFLMAO!!!
    The only “movement” I have seen is a bowel movement by one slug defecating on a police car.
    Other than that….they just lay there and stink up Wall street.
    Must be doing hell with the ozone.

  • Anonymous

    Good Luck with that my friend.

  • Anonymous

    Good Luck with that my friend.

  • AliveStillKickin

    Is that all you got….
    ROFLMAO!!!

  • Anonymous

    Keep a rolling and laughing. I’m glad to bring such joy to you;-+

  • Nancillarypeloslinton

    I’m glad that you accept that Obama’s corruption in bailing out Wall Street and the banks has shown that he paid back his campaign contributors. Barack Obama took more money from Wall Street and the banks during his presidential campaign than any other candidate in American history. Talk about corruption!

  • unmutual

    The human microphone thing is creepy. Like Jonestown/Heaven’s Gate kind of creepy.  

  • Pablo

    But then we’d never hear from him at all!

    Hey, that’s a great idea!

  • Cecelia

     http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs/brad-bannon/2010/09/09/Bank-Bailout-Spawned-Obama-and-Dems-Tea-Party-Problem

  • caconservative

    It’s IMMENSELY TELLING! When you have to listen to someone tell you what to think and say, YOU’VE LOST!!

  • caconservative

    Kinda like a seal, clapping and barking for a fish, isn’t it?

  • Tblue37

    You mean the one where Patrick Hawley, the conservative _American Spectator_ reporter who bragged in an article afterward that he was there only to discredit the movement, acted as an agent provacateur and rushed past the guards, only to realize the actual protesters were not following him in his invasion of the museum? Shouldn’t CONSERVATIVES be disavowing HIS lawbreaking and HIS attempts to incite violence?

  • Chayal Boded

    More like just plain annoying and schtoooopid!

  • http://twitter.com/RonCdeWeijze Ron C. de Weijze

    The
    extreme left of Michael Moore and Slavoj Zizek plus no doubt Noam Chomsky and
    if he could he would arise out of his grave Jacques Derrida, want to, repeat,
    WANT TO, no NEED TO own this movement. Anything to make it not look like a Tea
    Party gathering. What happens between people in the group must under no
    circumstances by what happens in people between groups. Before that happens,
    brains must have been washed by the ultra-left. It is okay to deconstruct the
    fabric of social reality into the nothingness these left elites supposedly live
    and have lived themselves, but it is not okay not to let people constructively
    recollect their own backgrounds, pride, joy and happiness. That is exactly
    where the defecating on police cars begins, where the smile on Moore’s face
    widens twice as much, where the old hippies congratulate themselves for bein
    the new elites, as if that really changes anything. As long as people are not
    allowed to be their own person with a voice, but must as individuals submit to
    the group, on the left, just like groups must submit to the top dog on the
    right, groupsism is just as bad as cronyism and the dangers of polarization may
    be greater, since people on the left don’t even CARE that they lose themselves
    for the group. As sociology has taught us, the canvas of society is made of
    power-distances and as long as mobs can make it look as if everybody is equal
    and everybody is together during the mobbing, the new elites can position and
    divide everybody between them, after they won, which this is all about, no
    doubt.

  • Aryadne

    It’s creepy! PLEASE STOP!!!

    When everyone speaks at once it appears like this group of people shares a brain. As much as I support OWS, this kinda thing is creeping the F*** out of me!

    I don’t care how “effective” it is (which it’s not – because who can ever understand what a crowd of people says – it took me years to figure out that the Denver Broncos fans were yelling “IN-COM-PLETE” and they’ve been doing it since god knows when). It seriously sounds like groupthink.

    Not only that but repetitve speaking is used in memorizing and brainwashing. Not that anyone at OWS is trying to influence or brainwash anyone else, but they could inadvertently do so. If a large group of people chant something, even once, it has far more legitimacy in the subconscious than just one person’s words.

    PLEASE, I SERIOUSLY BEG YOU TO STOP! It’s not cute or clever. It’s creepy and potentially dangerous.

  • Anonymous

    insane

  • Anonymous

    Nothing I disagree with here.

  • Shogan83

    No, it’s entirely a ‘human microphone’ thing.  You should attend a general assembly, where these are used most often.  Most often, this is used to spread information about procedure and proposals for people to vote on.  Occasionally, they’ll have a speaker and this will be used.I have yet to hear a person there decry the ‘individual’.  

  • Anonymous

    The TARP money loaned to the banks was paid back in full with interest. The bankers that packaged the high risk housing loans should have been prosecuted.

  • Nancillarypeloslinton

    So, you were probably the typical corrupt, millionaire wannabe making probably 50-75K a year and you figured damn right I deserve that $500,000 home with a subprime, adjustable rate mortgage didn’t you? After all those bankers and politicians twisted your arm and forced you to sign the paper work. You’re probably also pissing and whining because the $75,000 student loan you took out to be a chef somewhere that pays only $12.50 an hour and you want the government to forget about it. YOU’RE A VICTIM, CORRECT? You’re a fucking punk!

  • Anonymous

    It sounds like mindless drones that came straight out of Children of The Corn. 

  • Anonymous

    Jim Jones is laughing in his grave.

  • Anonymous

    Subject: [mediaite] Re: Occupy Wall Street’s ‘Human Microphone’: Insanely Brilliant…Or Just Insane?

  • Anonymous

    Although I agree with this post, it is not mine. I have posted 2 replies about OWS and both have not appeared on this page.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_YJOFCUW4S62AICSGYG562VMHZY Marje

    It takes all kinds to make a movement…..and your attitude is offensive.

    Those who finally are taking the initiative in rebelling against the uber right wing destructive attitude and actions against our country may not be the countryclubby churchy authoritarian bunch who have been having their loud and rambunctious say up to now,  but they are just as entitled to make a fuss as those tea potties that disturbed public meetings in my community. 

    Your cant is contrived and canned by the people who attract your attention on the TV, and thinking people recognize this…..

  • Angelo R. Mozilo

    I think you mean: Jim Jones, JIM JONES, is laughing, IS LAUGHING, in his grave, ISNT THIS GRAY

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Josh-Coppersmith-Heaven/100000912393205 Josh Coppersmith Heaven

    Its an effective way for a single speaker to be heard by a lot of people. Its simple, and it works. I don’t see how problem-solving suddenly became a reason to call a group a cult.

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Self-Serve Advertising | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram