1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough

Biggest Leak In US Military History: WikiLeaks Posts Thousands Of Classified Docs On Afghan War

updated
» 53 comments

Early Sunday, in what is being called “one of the biggest leaks in US military history,” the whistleblower site WikiLeaks posted tens of thousands of classified “military field reports” about the Afghan war. According to the New York Times, the Times, the Guardian, and the German newspaper Der Spiegel were “given access to the voluminous records several weeks ago on the condition that they not report on the material before Sunday.”

Based on that access and reporting, which WikiLeaks was not involved in, the New York Times has published a series of articles today which are too lengthy to go through here in detail but, broadly speaking, conclude that the Afghan war is not going as well as official reports might lead the public to believe. You can read a rundown of what they reveal here.

Perhaps equally as interesting is how the Times decided what to report on from the thousands of classified documents they were given access to. The paper explains its thinking in a note to readers.

Deciding whether to publish secret information is always difficult, and after weighing the risks and public interest, we sometimes chose not to publish. But there are times when the information is of significant public interest, and this is one of those times. The documents illuminate the extraordinary difficulty of what the United States and its allies have undertaken in a way that other accounts have not.

Most of the incident reports are marked “secret,” a relatively low level of classification. The Times has taken care not to publish information that would harm national security interests. The Times and the other news organizations agreed at the outset that we would not disclose — either in our articles or any of our online supplementary material — anything that was likely to put lives at risk or jeopardize military or antiterrorist operations.

You can read the Guardian’s report on the leaks here.

Update: The White House is not happy about this. At all. From Mike Allen.

White House National Security Adviser James Jones issued a statement that begins: “The United States strongly condemns the disclosure of classified information by individuals and organizations which could put the lives of Americans and our partners at risk, and threaten our national security.

“Wikileaks made no effort to contact us about these documents – the United States government learned from news organizations that these documents would be posted. These irresponsible leaks will not impact our ongoing commitment to deepen our partnerships with Afghanistan and Pakistan; to defeat our common enemies; and to support the aspirations of the Afghan and Pakistani people.

The statement says nothing about the three newspapers that reported extensively on the leaks. However, in their note to readers the NYT does say that “to establish confidence in the information, The Times checked a number of the reports against incidents that had been publicly reported or witnessed by our own journalists. Government officials did not dispute that the information was authentic” suggesting that the government was at least aware these docs were out there and being examined.

Update #2: Michael Calderone confirms the administration was indeed aware the NYT had the documents. New York Times Washington bureau chief Dean Baquet tells Calderone: “I did in fact go the White House and lay out for them what we had…We did it to give them the opportunity to comment and react. They did. They also praised us for the way we handled it, for giving them a chance to discuss it, and for handling the information with care. And for being responsible.”

Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • shootfromthehip

    Whenever you hear or read in the news that a helicopter “crashed,” you better think twice. The military does not want anyone to know that choppers are frequently brought down by enemy fire.

    It’s just a shame we have to read about all this years after the fact.

    Where are the real war reporters?

    What we’ve had for the past decade are stenographers.

    Just what the Pentagon wants.

    And this is unacceptable!

    “An airstrike in Azizabad, in western Afghanistan, killed as many as 92 people in August 2008. In May 2009, another strike killed 147 Afghan civilians.”

    Get OUT of Afghanistan NOW.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua-Taj-Bozeman/661000669 Joshua Taj Bozeman

    Great idea. Get out of Afghanistan now. If that isn’t the most simplistic view possible, I’ve no idea what is.

    You do remember what happened as the result of Afghanistan being occupied and run by a terrorist organization, right? Go to down Manhattan and take a look at the hole if you need a clue.

  • shootfromthehip

    Hey FUCKHOLE.

    The terrorists who brought down the twin towers were from Saudi Arabia.

  • murf

    As someone who served in Iraq , the founder of Wikileaks , should be beheaded in a soccer field Saddam & Afghanistan Taliban style !

    DailyKos is celebrating ..

  • shootfromthehip

    You want simplistic?

    I’ll give it to you very simple: we cannot be all over teh word and be the world’s policeman any more. We cannot afford it. You ok with your taxes being raised so we can continute to be in Afghanistan another 10 years? Not me.

    There will always be terrorists in the world in any number of countries. We cannot invade them all.

    A smarter way is to have small covert CIA-led operations. Not sending in massive armies.

    We need to work with Pakistan, India and other neighboring countries to fix the mess.

    Military “solutions” are not working, they are hurting.

    We are only creating MORE terrorist and people that hate America with every errant bomb that maims or kills an innocent.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua-Taj-Bozeman/661000669 Joshua Taj Bozeman

    Why isn’t the story that the folks at Wikileaks are nutjobs whose goal is to cause trouble and get people killed? The NY Times notes they won’t release any documents that might cause danger to people, but the lunatics at Wikileaks have no such compunction.

  • shootfromthehip

    Glad to know you openly advocate for the murder of someone, Murf.

    Thank you for your service, now go cool off by firing a few rounds into a non-living target.

  • murf

    Shootfromthehip

    Who are one utterly clueless piece of shit liberal who spouts nothing but spoon- fed Dailykos talking points..

    Go to hell

  • shootfromthehip

    Sucks to loose to someone smarter than you, doesn’t it Murf?

    Fuck Daily Kos and fuck you.

    I get my talking points from NO ONE.

  • murf

    You go to Iraq and you see the joy and gratitude in the eyes of the Iraqi people , that thank us for what we did , then get back to me to on your narrow minded brain dead ideology .

    Liberals love spreading peace and love but only in movies.

  • shootfromthehip

    I don’t do talking points. I do the truth.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua-Taj-Bozeman/661000669 Joshua Taj Bozeman

    shootfromthehip said:
    Hey FUCKHOLE.The terrorists who brought down the twin towers were from Saudi Arabia.

    Ah. Okay, so the Talbian didn’t harbor bin laden, and they had nothing to do with the plot. Got ya. Silly me.

    Mature by the way. I’m a fuckhole.

  • felixw

    shootfromthehip said:
    I don’t do talking points. I do the truth.

    Does that include your use of the word FUCKHOLE in all caps? As in your previous post?

  • shootfromthehip

    The joy of these dead civilians, perhaps?

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Lt_DfYKH0Q&feature=related

    Or maybe the joy a mother feels when her only son loses limbs to an errant U.S. bomb?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua-Taj-Bozeman/661000669 Joshua Taj Bozeman

    shootfromthehip said:
    You want simplistic? I’ll give it to you very simple: we cannot be all over teh word and be the world’s policeman any more. We cannot afford it. You ok with your taxes being raised so we can continute to be in Afghanistan another 10 years? Not me.There will always be terrorists in the world in any number of countries. We cannot invade them all.A smarter way is to have small covert CIA-led operations. Not sending in massive armies.We need to work with Pakistan, India and other neighboring countries to fix the mess. Military “solutions” are not working, they are hurting.We are only creating MORE terrorist and people that hate America with every errant bomb that maims or kills an innocent.

    I agree. Military solutions don’t work. I mean, historically, they’ve worked wonders, but let’s forget facts for a bit and pretend that diplomacy is the way to go. So, after the attack of 911, you would’ve just allowed al qaeda its home base in Afghanistan? Just allowed the taliban to continue offering aid in support and the infrastructure of a nation? We should have just sat back and waited for the next attack, huh?

    Like I said- simplistic.

  • shootfromthehip

    Yes it does.

    I will call it as I see it.

    The truth is I feel that Joshua is a fuckhole for calling my worldview simplistic.

  • shootfromthehip

    Ok Joshua, I take back the “fuckhole” comment. You’ve got some nuance to ya.

  • shootfromthehip

    “So, after the attack of 911, you would’ve just allowed al qaeda its home base in Afghanistan? Just allowed the taliban to continue offering aid in support and the infrastructure of a nation?”

    No, I woud have gone in there with the initial strike, as we did, but then I would have ordered troops OUT.

    And ordered INTERNATIONAL peacekeepers IN.

    But left CIA in as well.

  • murf

    Liberals don’t give a damn about the troops , they are ALL blind sheep who just parrot talking points .

    Just like DADT policy since when did the Left care so much about the military ?

    Let’s remember folk this is the same Left who spit on and called the Vietnam Vets ” baby killers ”

    Its allllllllll about ” the progressive movement ”

    Let’s get real .

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua-Taj-Bozeman/661000669 Joshua Taj Bozeman

    shootfromthehip said:
    “So, after the attack of 911, you would’ve just allowed al qaeda its home base in Afghanistan? Just allowed the taliban to continue offering aid in support and the infrastructure of a nation?”No, I woud have gone in there with the initial strike, as we did, but then I would have ordered troops OUT. And ordered INTERNATIONAL peacekeepers IN.But left CIA in as well.

    Well that doesn’t work too well when no one seems to have any balls these days. How do we order international troops around? You really think we could just be like, “yo, NATO, take over…we’ll be seeing ya. Good luck with it.” ??

    It’s not the most wonderful of situations, but how do you just leave? You leave and everyone knows what happens- the taliban takes back over, they call up bin laden, “hey, how goes it? swing back by, they left. we’ve got some big planning to do!’ Then when the next attack happens, do we go back in or do we just say screw it and wait for the next attack?

    Maybe we change the rules of engagement which are screwing our guys over? Maybe we get to the root of the problem and stop being so PC that we’re scared to death to admit the root of the problem is a backward 7th century political ideology with death at its core?

  • shootfromthehip

    “How do we order international troops around?”

    Very skilled diplomacy. Bush and his team did not have the capacity to rally the international community to help. He MIGHT have been able to, had he not messed it up by invading Iraq. But that’s all history now…..it could have been done, though.

    “It’s not the most wonderful of situations, but how do you just leave?”

    That is the hardest question indeed. But hard times call for hard answers.

    It’s been done before and the world survived (see Vietnam etc…).

  • murf

    Every Democracy has been made possible because of war .

  • shootfromthehip

    Dear “Murf.” You do not speak for all liberals.

    Nice antiquated stereotypes you have.

    Please let us know when you wake up in 2010, where the liberals are U.S. vets in charge of Congress and looking our FOR our troops (see John Kerry, Jim Webb, John Murtha R.I.P and on and on)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua-Taj-Bozeman/661000669 Joshua Taj Bozeman

    I wouldn’t want to be in a position of trying to compare vietnam with afghanistan. We didn’t risk the vietcong coming over here with suitcase nukes or flying planes into skyscrapers. I fear just leaving would mean a disaster for the US, and the govts main job is to protect the populace. I don’t think the most skilled diplomacy would gather the intl community around. They did help in afghanistan, but look how quickly so many of them lost the will to stay in the fight? Wars aren’t won overnight, unfortunately.

  • shootfromthehip

    Democracy got Hammas elected.

    True story!

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_legislative_election,_2006

    Talk about simplistic, you cons understand very little about the world.

    Guess that’s why you swallowed all of GW Bush’s dumb platitudes.

  • murf

    Diplomacy — Thats really working out isn’t ?

    Sanctions on Nkorea and Iran are really making them think twice

    The United Nations has become such a bargaining chip , Nkorea and Iran are thinking twice now before striving to attain nuclear weapons .. LOL

  • Pablo

    shootfromthehip said:
    And ordered INTERNATIONAL peacekeepers IN.

    Oh, you mean like an International Security Assistance Force? Damn, why didn’t anybody think of that?

  • shootfromthehip

    “:Wars aren’t won overnight, unfortunately.”

    That much is very true.

    But the reality is that Al Queda are mostly dead or long ago escaped into Pakistan.

    We simply cannot afford to be there any longer while our own country suffers in debt.

    I’d rater build better roads and bridges here than in Kabul.

    What about you?

  • murf

    Shootfromthehip — Ill give you credit for Jim Webb .

  • shootfromthehip

    “Iran are thinking twice now before striving to attain nuclear weapons”

    Actually diplomacy IS working in he case of Iran.

  • shootfromthehip

    Thanks Murf.

    Webb is one of the good ones.

    And I’ll give you credit for your service. Sincerely.

  • Pablo

    Please let us know when you wake up in 2010, where the liberals are U.S. vets in charge of Congress and looking our FOR our troops (see John Kerry, Jim Webb, John Murtha R.I.P and on and on)

    Zombie Murtha back in Congress?

    *shudder*

  • Pablo

    shootfromthehip said:
    Actually diplomacy IS working in he case of Iran.

    How can you tell?

  • shootfromthehip

    Because they don’t have an A-Bomb yet, do they?

  • progress

    We must leave Afghanistan. No one ever wins in war, and it’s a moral outrage.

  • Pablo

    Is there something about the word “yet” that shows a change in the track of the situation from wich one could reasonably conclude that diplomacy is having a positive effect in regard to Iran? This does not indicate diplomatic success: Ex-CIA chief: Strike on Iran seems more likely now

  • Jelperman

    murf said:
    As someone who served in Iraq , the founder of Wikileaks , should be beheaded in a soccer field Saddam & Afghanistan Taliban style !

    DailyKos is celebrating ..

    And you should be castrated with a rusty olive fork.

  • Jelperman

    felixw said:
    Does that include your use of the word FUCKHOLE in all caps? As in your previous post?

    It’s the truth: the guy is a fuckhole.

  • Jelperman

    murf said:
    Every Democracy has been made possible because of war .

    Iceland wasn’t created by a war.

  • timzank

    shootfromthehip said:
    Hey FUCKHOLE. The terrorists who brought down the twin towers were from Saudi Arabia.

    Who ran where immediately for shelter fuckhole?

  • timzank

    Pablo said:
    Zombie Murtha back in Congress?*shudder*

    Murtha didn’t do shit for the troops, he did it all for his constituents, they all enjoyed the gazillions that fat old pork fucking leech brought into PA. The troops he accused of cold blooded murder…

    Despicable untrustworthy old dirtbag.

  • murf

    Jelperman — I will assume you are a proud member of the Westboro Baptist Church .

  • notsofast

    shootfromthehip said:
    The terrorists who brought down the twin towers were from Saudi Arabia.

    You asshole- they were members of AQ and were trained in Afghanistan.- you fking lib commie cowards always try to re-write history.

    Well, rewrite this: FU!!

  • notsofast

    shootfromthehip said:
    Democracy got Hammas elected.

    It also got Hitler, Mao, Saddam Hussein, etc elected.

    What is your point, asshole baby?

  • notsofast

    shootfromthehip said:
    There will always be terrorists in the world in any number of countries. We cannot invade them all.

    Who said we should?

    shootfromthehip said:
    A smarter way is to have small covert CIA-led operations. Not sending in massive armies.

    We need to work with Pakistan, India and other neighboring countries to fix the mess.

    We already did that!!! The CIA was the first in, months before the military.

    And, yes, India and Pakistan have really stepped up haven’t they?

    Next!

  • shootfromthehip

    “What is your point, asshole baby?”

    My point is, genius, that Bush’s (and the commenter above) seems to think imposing Democracy at the barrel of a fun is somehow a noble cause.

    It is not,

    And even IF Democracy flourishes in Iraq, doesn’t mean we will like the results (see Hammas winning in Palestine).

  • shootfromthehip

    barrel of a GUN, I meant.

  • notsofast

    shootfromthehip said:
    And even IF Democracy flourishes in Iraq, doesn’t mean we will like the results (see Hammas winning in Palestine).

    Well we sure as hell can try to steer them on the right path.

  • Integr8d

    I don’t see how the neo-cons would be anything but thrilled at Obama’s foreign policy; It’s exactly the same as Bush’s…

    If people actually had to pay, directly in taxes, for these wars, they might think twice about just how much they want them. And if they still wanted them, I have little doubt that they’d argue for finding something more cost-effective.

    170 South African PMC soldiers were able to do what 80,000 UN troops couldn’t. THAT’S cost-effective.

  • Azarkhan

    I hope the US government will have Mr. Julian Assange assassinated.

  • NORBIT

    Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman John Kerry…said in a written statement that “however illegally” the documents were released, they raise “serious questions” about U.S. policy toward the region.
    ————————————————————————————————————————————–

    More Classic HYPOCRISY / DISHONESTY from the LEFT!!

    Compare above to how the Left RAILLED against the “illegality” of how the ACORN tapes were obtained!
    ——————————————————————————–

    EXPOSED – The lying left, & their media!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lars-Svensen/100001028197161 Lars Svensen

    Now the whole world will know…the actual size of Billary’s pantsuits.

  • http://none pyrope

    There is freedom of the press and there is treason. Disclosing classified materials is treason.

    On war: I wish I did not know this but I do; there is one reason to fight a war and that is to win it as quickly and decisively as possible. Why? War is a horrible thing, and it is not to be dwelt upon or gloried in.

    A quick and expeditious victory minimizes the loss of life and the costs involved in fighting a war. This was the basis for Sun Tzu’s “The Art of War.” Since 11 September 2001, for one reason or another, the US has failed to prosecute the war on terror in a manner that has resulted in the victory that should have been won over a bunch of third-rate hooligans. One should have thought this lesson would have well been learned in Vietnam. Unfortunately, it apparently was not.

    This has been to our own undoing in that our failure to gain a decisive victory has emboldened numerous tin-horn thugs to the point where they are now challenging and threatening the US. (North Korea, Iran, Venezuela) As a result of our government’s dithering and failure to seek victory, more of our best and brightest are sacrificed to the monster that is war.

    By all accounts, bin Laden’s head should have been placed on a pike in the capitol square of Krapistan. Every terrorist should have been taking the “dirt nap,” and our troops should be home with their families and loved ones. Instead, the US allows itself to be hamstrung by our own politicians who want to make political hay, and by the UN–all of which is to the detriment of those whom are truly our “best and brightest.”

    Will our government learn its lesson on the folly of politicizing war? I very seriously doubt it.

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Self-Serve Advertising | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram