Billy Eichner Grills Virgin ‘Bachelor’ Colton Underwood: Maybe You’re Gay And ‘We Don’t Even Know’ Yet

Colton Underwood, America’s first virgin “Bachelor”, sat down with comedian Billy Eichner for a serious man-to-man talk on Monday’s episode of ABC’s hit show.

Eichner grilled the 26-year-old Bachelor star, who has never experienced sexual intercourse, on his commitment to remain abstinent until he falls in love.

“You’re gonna wait until you get married?” asks Eichner.

“I’m gonna wait until I’m in love,” Underwood says, flashing a subtle smile, because he knows at least twenty girls in the background are swooning over him.

“Fine, you get an award,” says Eichner, skeptically, “but let’s say then you have sex, and the sex is bad?”

When Underwood suggests he expects the sex will get better if he’s in love with a woman, Eichner shakes his head, adding in an aside that he’s never seen this many virgins since he had guest-hosted The View.

“I’m gay. I know that’s a shock, Colton. That, I think you should look into,” Eichner says, joking: “Maybe you’re the first gay ‘Bachelor’ and we don’t even know… put that in your promo.”