1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough

Cue Hysterical Town Hall Mob Over New Black Panther Case

video
» 41 comments

Mission: Accomplished. In a search for a sequel to last year’s Summer of Angst over health care reform, the “manufactured menace” of a New Black Panther-controlled election has gripped California’s 27th District. In a video featured on Fox News earlier yesterday, Rep. Brad Sherman (D-Ca) was asked about the case, to wild applause. The applause, however, turned to jeers at his assurance that the DOJ is not anti-white, and hysterical jeering when he said he didn’t know about the NBPP case. It’s gonna be a long summer.


And so, it begins. The same people who were scared stiff that uninsured deadbeats might get access to the same government health care that they have are now nearly apoplectic that the Obama Justice Department is somehow sticking it to the White Man. When will Whitey catch a goddam break?

This reaction is exactly what this story is designed for, and is the culmination of a two-plus year campaign to, in my opinion, unfairly conflate the New Black Panther Party with President Obama, and raise the specter of a nation in the grip of black militancy.

During the 2008 presidential campaign, opponents of then-Senator Barack Obama repeatedly tried to conflate him with the NBPP by virtue of a web page in an open Barack Obama forum, one that was subsequently removed. On Election Day, the McCain campaign tried to exploit what everyone agrees was an isolated incident, while the polls were still open. The story cooled quickly, and rightly so. These were the actions of a single individual, and were considered nothing more than a nuisance by the Philadelphia police, who simply asked him to leave.

Contrary to what some are reporting, the Department of Justice provided detailed legal explanations for dropping the judgments against the New Black Panther Party, its Chairman, and the unarmed poll-watcher, but it’s really common sense. There is no evidence to support those charges. I spoke to NBPP Chairman Malik Shabazz days after the incident, and he fully admitted to having sent party members to over 300 polling places throughout the country, all in predominantly black districts, with strict instructions to act within the law. If his mission was in fact to intimidate voters, that makes about 299 disobedient New Black Panthers.

That is not to say that media outlets shouldn’t be covering this story. As has been pointed out on this site that the injection of race makes this a third-rail story, but that doesn’t mean it can’t be handled responsibly. As is often the case, the focus here is on whether the story should be covered, and not how it is covered.

Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • kenm

    “When will Whitey catch a goddam break?”

    You’re despicable Tommy.

    Also, why is it that we can vote user comments up or down but not the article itself? Seems like it might be useful for Mediaite to know which of their contributors consistently post well-regarded articles, and which don’t. Guess which list you would find yourself on Tommy?

  • tiredofbs

    Holy Crap!
    Media/Journ0list corruption, in plain view.
    The article above is totally & completely a propaganda piece,
    a Lewinsky event for Obama of unimaginable proportions.

    TC:”The same people who were scared stiff that uninsured deadbeats might get access to the same government health care that they have are now nearly apoplectic that the Obama Justice Department is somehow sticking it to the White Man. When will Whitey catch a goddam break? ”

    Holy crap! R U Kiddin me?
    I knew this Site would slowly morh into a Media Matters/Kos type as
    elections were closing in, I just never thought it would be so fast & so blatant…

  • kenm

    tiredofbs said:
    I knew this Site would slowly morh into a Media Matters/Kos type as
    elections were closing in, I just never thought it would be so fast & so blatant

    Most of the Mediaite journalists are pretty good and at least try to be fair even though it’s impossible to completely hide your biases. The problem is mainly Tommy Christopher who is just an unabashed progressive cheerleader with absolutely no regard for objectivity.

  • MichelleF

    Kenm,
    I don’t have a problem with Jon, but Colby, Frances, and Glynnis are no better than Tommy.

  • tatboy

    OK… lets get this straight. Tommy is a liberal. He is not ashamed of it and mentions it in a lot of his interviews. He is NOT pulling a Dave W (who let the Wash Po put out that he was a conservative without him correcting the record). He is allowed to be a liberal and write his opinion about the media and how stories are covered.
    Geees, we bitch about the MSM/Katie Couric types that lie to our faces that they’re an “unbiased source of facts”, AND bitch about an honest liberal that comes to a story from HIS PERSPECTIVE. Tommy is not hiding his bias… isn’t that what a lot of us were asking for from reporters? He writes good print from his perspective that he is allowed to have and we get to comment on… isn’t that the point? And kinda fun?
    I disagree with Tommy on a lot of what he writes. I have liberal views and conservative ones… Penn & Teller are MY hero’s :). But I like to read what he writes (and I like Dave W too, he just should have been more honest when WaPo put him out as a conservative) so I come here. His writing is smart, and he backs up his statements with documentation. Yes the DOJ did release a document explaining that the dropped the NBPP case after a no-show by the defendants got them a conviction… that is a fact. Should they have? Well I don’t think the DOJ would have dropped a no-show conviction of the KKK… but that is my opinion.

  • Puter Boi

    MichelleF said:
    I don’t have a problem with Jon, but Colby, Frances, and Glynnis are no better than Tommy.

    Colby has better hair.

  • TfT

    Once again, Tommy, the White House Correspondent, shows who it is he is working for, and it ain’t the little people.

  • MichelleF

    Puter, Colby loves to email me and tell me to “check myself”, and then hide under his desk when I respond, which is why I include him. I think he’s a liberal coward. At least Tommy has the guts to confront people who call him out.

  • http://apostrophejones.com Apostrophe jones

    Flash ! Hysterical Washington Stenographer Strikes Again !

  • tiredofbs

    JUst look at the headlines today.

    THE ONLY REASON this Site has gotten some legitimacy,
    as to being something other then the usual Left Wing BS Rag, is
    the (almost) effort to include some *reality or facts, among
    their Left Wing propaganda.
    As of today, I see clearly, they have decided to start leaping further Left.

    Headline:”NBC And CBS Reject Ground Zero Mosque Ad..FOR GOOD REASON (?)
    by Glynnis MacNicol |

    I guess we’ll have to wait & see.

    Declaring/admitting Political preference & opinions, is commendable.
    Lying spinning 7 completely altering facts is not ..It’s just shady

  • tiredofbs

    MichelleF said:
    Puter, Colby loves to email me and tell me to “check myself”,

    How interesting!
    NO…No usual bias here…

  • libra blue

    I think Tommy is one of those who jumped up and cheered when OJ was acquitted. How’s that search for the “real killer” going Tommy?

  • tiredofbs

    Puter Boi said:
    Puter Boi says:
    July 14, 2010 at 5:54 pm Puter Boi(Quote)

    MichelleF said:
    I don’t have a problem with Jon, but Colby, Frances, and Glynnis are no better than Tommy.

    Colby has better hair.

    MichelleF said:
    Puter, Colby loves to email me and tell me to “check myself”,

    PuterBoi

    I’m guessing that is your E-mail buddy MichelleF..
    I guess he lurks :::eye roll::::

  • mproust

    Tommy, you really are a putz. I can’t imagine how, when, or why any organization (other than Mediaite) would ever hire you.

  • tiredofbs

    mproust said:
    mproust says:
    July 14, 2010 at 6:25 pm mproust(Quote

    Tommy, you really are a putz. I can’t imagine how, when, or why any organization (other than Mediaite) would ever hire you.

    R U Kidding?
    He would carry water for “Queefy Olberdouche” (not mine but I love it)
    or Ed Shultz +any1 @PMSNBC

  • The_Reasonable_Lib

    I must not have gotten the chain e-mail from my old conservative grammy.

  • Tommy Christopher

    As others (http://www.mediaite.com/online/cue-hysterical-town-hall-mob-over-new-black-panther-case/#comment-92108) have pointed out, I don’t make any bones about my point of view. I’ll still stand behind my record of fairness, and when I deliver an opinion, I support it. I’m not a “progressive cheerleader” or water carrier, as even a quick review of my work will indicate. Like me, you’re all entitled to your own opinions, but not your own facts.

  • http://SailRabbits.com Magister

    I commented to the thread yesterday that there was no reason for the Congressman to know about the controversy because it’s not before either of his committees, there’s no bill before Congress and it has nothing to do with his district.

    Of course Megyn Kelly (and possibly others at Fox News) apparently believes that every member of Congress should be aware of every single issue and I’m guessing they think that FNC should be the sole source for all info, but I’m going to assume that after the Town Hall video went viral every Congressperson’s staff prepared a brief for their member.

    IOW: I’d be somewhat surprised, if it happens again.

  • lanquihue

    Tommy, I don’t understand the crusade to pooh-pooh the story. As Mediaite has noted, a liberal group has accused Obama of using voter intimidation tactics during the primaries. Who knows if this is true, but, combined with the nbpp story, don’t you think it’s a bit premature to mock the story out of hand?

    The knock on the nbpp story is that it’s an isolated thing, two guys who didn’t really intimidate anyone, but on the other hand, and this is the easiest what-if in the world, if anyone thinks that two skinheads under similar circumstances would have had their civil case dropped, is an idiot.

  • tatboy

    And all of you hating on Tommy right now, remember this. He is the one who sacrificed his job at AOL to report on the Playboy Conservative Women Hatef@#% article and how wrong it was. If his ONLY ethic was to hate on conservative/Republicans he would not have sacrificed in a real monetary way for people he “hated”. How many of you would sacrifice your JOBS and stand up for people on the other side of the isle? Yes he is a liberal and his articles are going to be tinged that way, but you guys obviously like reading him since your here. Notice i didn’t say agree with him, I said reading him. I don’t agree with him… i like his writing. Period.

  • tjl

    Again, this is the far-right proving something we already know: they are afraid of black people…. BOO!

  • lanquihue

    tjl said:
    Again, this is the far-right proving something we already know: they are afraid of black people…. BOO!

    That’s kinda funny actually… Seeing as how the naacp talks about the tea party, sounds like they’re a bunch of iddy biddy fraidy cats. :) Oh my gosh, all those old white people might kick my ass! Oh no!!

  • Azarkhan

    “Cue Hysterical Town Hall Mob Over New Black Panther Case”

    Cue ignorant congressman and Tommy Christopher, leftist hack and apologist.

  • Snipzor

    Wasn’t that case thrown out, before Obama was in office (Yes it was, actually)? Or would that fact conflict too much with the right-wing neo-racism worldview?

    That silly reality and its liberal bias.

  • http://www.karlspensen.blogspot.com Karl Spensen

    Seeing a CROWD of ANGRY Right-Thinking Americans HYSTERICALY HECKLE a political candidate to score CHEAP POLITICAL POINTS gives me almost as much of a raging Freedom Chubby as calling a LIB “racist”!!!1 GO TO IT, True Patriots … with every SCREAM and RANT, you make our Movement MORE LEGITIMATE!!!1

  • tatboy

    Snipzor said:
    Wasn’t that case thrown out, before Obama was in office (Yes it was, actually)? Or would that fact conflict too much with the right-wing neo-racism worldview?

    That silly reality and its liberal bias.

    No… actually on the facts of this one you are wrong. I don’t know about “morally” wrong, but you are factually wrong. The defendants were found guilty due to not appearing in court… they were actually convicted. The Eric Holder DOJ reviewed the case and felt that had they actually had to try the case they would not have won, so they dropped it against all defendants accept one. TC has linked this document to many of his writings and you should do yourself a favor and read it before making statements that are wrong on the facts. As was said you are entitled to your opinions, not your own facts.

    Now would Eric holder have dropped a case against the KKK, White Knights, or other WHITE racist groups. I don’t think they would have. They would have wanted, in my opinion, to make a statement that voters will not be intimidated… or something to that effect. As for FOX “trotting out” the NBPP to perform a “minstrel show”, I’m sure they will stop when Keith Olbermann and eveyrone at MSNBC stops using the word raciest every 5 minutes and “trotting out” that idiot with the ni@@ers sign at a tea party rally.

  • Big_F-ing_Deal

    “When will Whitey catch a goddam break? ”

    Classic. :)

  • tiredofbs

    Yes he is a liberal and his articles are going to be ****tinged**** that way,
    but you guys obviously like reading him since your here.
    ———–

    Just look at the article above!
    That’s not **tinged*** that’s lies and spin from drama central.

    “Hysterical?” Or:”the “manufactured menace” of a New Black Panther-controlled
    election(?) has gripped California’s 27th District.

    People at the Town Hall were shocked at the B*lls of Rep Brad Sherman to LIE To
    their faces w/the lame “I know nothing a bout this”

    I’m sorry, Tommy Christopher may be entitled to his own
    flawed Left Wing opinions, but not HIS own facts!

  • writer

    Too bad some panthers weren’t there with clubs. They could have clubbed the crowd into submission.

  • Tommy Christopher

    lanquihue said:
    Tommy, I don’t understand the crusade to pooh-pooh the story. As Mediaite has noted, a liberal group has accused Obama of using voter intimidation tactics during the primaries. Who knows if this is true, but, combined with the nbpp story, don’t you think it’s a bit premature to mock the story out of hand?

    The knock on the nbpp story is that it’s an isolated thing, two guys who didn’t really intimidate anyone, but on the other hand, and this is the easiest what-if in the world, if anyone thinks that two skinheads under similar circumstances would have had their civil case dropped, is an idiot.

    Good points that I will answer honestly. That “liberal group” thing is bigger bullshit than the NBPP story, and I ought to know. I starred in another documentary about it called “The Audacity of Democracy.” http://www.amazon.com/Audacity-Democracy-Film-Brad-Special/dp/B001POGTMI
    These people were abetted by Fox News for months, but couldn’t stand up to real questioning.

    As for whether Holder would have dropped cases against the Knights Party, for example, I’m positive he would have. As I told Malik during our interview, the Knights are very practiced at staying on the right side of the law, rhetoric-wise. A bad case is a bad case.

  • Pablo

    Mission: Accomplished. In a search for a sequel to last year’s Summer of Angst over health care reform, the “manufactured menace” of a New Black Panther-controlled election has gripped California’s 27th District. In a video featured on Fox News earlier yesterday, Rep. Brad Sherman (D-Ca) was asked about the case, to wild applause. The applause, however, turned to jeers at his assurance that the DOJ is not anti-white, and hysterical jeering when he said he didn’t know about the NBPP case. It’s gonna be a long summer.

    Yeah. And it looks like the US Commission on Civil Rights is watching stupid Faux Nooz. July 14, 2010:

    Given the extraordinary testimony of Mr. Adams, we request that the Department reconsider
    its unwillingness to allow Mr. Coates to testify before the Commission. Mr. Coates’ testimony is
    vital to our investigation because he is in the best position to corroborate, deny, or provide
    additional information regarding the matters described by Mr. Adams. As far back as November
    2009, the Commission served a subpoena on Mr. Coates, who in his capacity as former Chief of the
    Voting Section and member of the New Black Panther Party trial team, appears to be a primary
    witness on the matters addressed by our investigation. In fact, the Department has previously
    allowed Mr. Coates to appear before the Commission in June 2008 regarding the Department’s
    enforcement of laws against voter intimidation and voter fraud. We renew our request that the
    Department cooperate with the Commission’s lawful subpoena and make Mr. Coates available to
    testify. Please contact our General Counsel, David Blackwood, as to Mr. Coates’ availability by
    July 21, 2010.

    It is with great regret that I must alert you to evidence of the possible unequal administration
    of justice in the Civil Rights Division. However, the Commission is charged under 42 U.S.C.
    §1975a(a)(2) with pursuing such claims. It is a statutory responsibility the agency does not
    undertake lightly. I sincerely hope you will pursue and investigate these charges and provide the
    Commission with the witnesses it needs to complete its important work.

    Buncha wingnuts, huh?

  • Pablo

    Magister said:
    I commented to the thread yesterday that there was no reason for the Congressman to know about the controversy because it’s not before either of his committees, there’s no bill before Congress and it has nothing to do with his district.

    He claims he hadn’t seen it in any of the media sources he normally consumes. I believe him.

  • http://SailRabbits.com Magister

    @Pablo: He really doesn’t look like a guy who gets a lot of television.
    Based on nothing but superficiality, he strikes me as a reader.

  • yweston

    Why isn’t Fox reporting this to the old Baggers??

    On Election Day, Nov. 6, 2006 a posse of three men in Tucson, Ariz., proved that the Wild West still lives.A group, which was three strong, and allegedly composed of two anti-immigration activists, Russ Dove and Roy Warden, carried a camcorder, a clipboard — on which, they said, was information about a proposed law to…… make English the state’s official language — one with an Armed 9mm Glock automatic strapped to his side. While one man would approach a voter, holding the clipboard, another would follow, pointing the video camera at them. The third would stand behind, holding his hand to the gun at his hip in what activists on the other side called classic voter intimidation tactics in a precinct one local paper had previously declared the bellwether of the area’s Hispanic vote.
    In that instance, the DOJ declined to bring any action for alleged voter intimidation, notwithstanding the requests of the complaining parties.

  • Latin2

    So are their CONSERVATIVE writers for Mediaite? You know to TRY to be balanaced?

    Sure Tommy, I don’t understand why a grown man would use the name “tommy”, states he is Liberal…but are there any CONSERVATIVE writers at Mediaite?

    If you believe in FAIRNESS.

    Considering the U.S. population is 40% Conservative, and only 20% Liberal…so where are the Conservative writers for Mediaite? Also Independents make up 40% and are leaving Obama behind…so where is the balance? There should be 40% stories written by Conservatives and only 20% of the stories written by Liberals according to the U.S. population

  • Latin2

    yweston said:
    Why isn’t Fox reporting this to the old Baggers??

    On Election Day, Nov. 6, 2006 a posse of three men in Tucson, Ariz., proved that the Wild West still lives.A group, which was three strong, and allegedly composed of two anti-immigration activists, Russ Dove and Roy Warden, carried a camcorder, a clipboard — on which, they said, was information about a proposed law to…… make English the state’s official language — one with an Armed 9mm Glock automatic strapped to his side. While one man would approach a voter, holding the clipboard, another would follow, pointing the video camera at them. The third would stand behind, holding his hand to the gun at his hip in what activists on the other side called classic voter intimidation tactics in a precinct one local paper had previously declared the bellwether of the area’s Hispanic vote.
    In that instance, the DOJ declined to bring any action for alleged voter intimidation, notwithstanding the requests of the complaining parties.

    Why is the MSM reporting that the Black Panther Party member who was standing in front of the voting place a CREDENTIALED DEMOCRATIC ward poll watcher?

  • Latin2

    I meant to write Why ISN’T the MSM reporting that Jerry Jackson, the New Black Panther Party member was a CREDENTIALED Democratic poll watcher?

    Meaning that the New Black Panther party member was a SANCTIONED Democratic ward poll watcher.

  • Pablo

    yweston said:
    Why isn’t Fox reporting this to the old Baggers??

    Let’s see. It’s a 4 year old story, there’s apparently no video evidence and it’s missing the DOJ whistleblower. You should go over there and give ‘em what for, though. Stomp your feet and stuff.

  • http://www.heartland.org/environmentandclimate-news.org/ClimateConference4 Just Tex


    Cue Hysterical so called “reporter Tommy Christopher to slander citizens with Leftist smears & outright bias!

  • http://www.heartland.org/environmentandclimate-news.org/ClimateConference4 Just Tex

    yweston said:
    On Election Day, Nov. 6, 2006 blah blah blah blah…

    Where’s the video? Is there any evidence at all, to support your allegation?

    Smear, lie & slander. That’s all you lying leftist lunatics have, to try to defend your own indefensible actions.

  • StewartIII

    “And he’s not the only one. Tommy Christopher at Mediaite came up with a Grand Unified Theory about Fox trying to “conflate” the Panther Party with Obama or something. Yeah, whatever. But then he pulled a Weigel:”

    ‘The Department of Justice provided detailed legal explanations for dropping the judgments against the New Black Panther Party, its Chairman, and the unarmed poll-watcher, but it’s really common sense. There is no evidence to support those charges.’

    “But here’s what that pesky [sworn testimony]* has to say about the “unarmed poll watcher”:”

    * http://www.usccr.gov/NBPH/04-23-2010_NBPPhearing.pdf

    MR. BULL: ‘There were two Black Panthers, one of them was armed, standing very close to each other, directly blocking the door to the polling places….’

    MR. HILL: ‘They were a team. They were acting in concert. They moved together.’

    MR. BULL: ‘They were uniformed.’

    MR. HILL: ‘Mr. Jackson took direction from Mr. Shabazz constantly. When he moved, Mr. Jackson moved, and it was a definite pattern. I don’t know if they worked it out ahead of time, but they were definitely moving in concert.’

    “To Mr Christopher this is “no evidence”. But to people who know the law, its called [aiding and abetting]*.”

    * http://www.lectlaw.com/def/a033.htm
    ***
    J$P: FOX Haters Week in Review!
    http://johnnydollar.us/files/100718fhwir.php

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Self-Serve Advertising | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram