1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough

Oh Come On! Some Media Outlets Already Questioning Birth Certificate Validity

» 54 comments

Within seconds of the most embarrassing presidential press conferences since Abraham Lincoln was forced to prove he was really dead by not breathing for 12 hours, the reaction on Twitter became the most interesting thing going. Everyone’s Twitter feeds had instantly been filled with a flurry of “certificate talk” (except for mine since I only follow the soothing thoughts of Taylor Swift). Some people were lamenting the time wasted, some were parsing President Obama’s words, and, amazingly, some already seemed to be questioning the document’s legitimacy. The amazing part, of course, isn’t that people were doing that. In fact, no one expects the certificate’s release to really change anything. The amazing part is who was questioning it.

Drudge Report posted this on Twitter:


Meanwhile, The Blaze and Fox News went for skeptical phrasing (Fox News image via Think Progress):



Now, this could easily just be careful journalism. After all, we live in the age of WikiLeaks so we should know better than just blindly accepting everything our government hands us. However, it’s not unfair to say that these aren’t examples of skepticism but rather cynicism. No one in the news media has ever believed anything about the Birther conspiracy except for one thing: those silly Birthers have a lot of eyes and those eyes mean traffic and ratings.

Look at every news site today (including our’s we must admit): they are all littered with birth certificate stories. Not because this story is more important than anything else (save perhaps the Royal Wedding) but because this is the SEO equivalent of oil bubbling out of the ground. For those of you who don’t blog for a living, let me explain it this way; I could have used the above headline and merely made this entire post an MS Paint drawing of Obama exiting his mother’s womb and it still would have done better traffic than the last ten posts I’ve written on every other subject. The search term “Obama birth certificate” is now making “Megan Fox naked” look like “The Paul Reiser Show air times.”

But, I suppose this is as it should be. The inevitable climax of the Birther story would have to be covered with a big explosion of cynicism and pandering. That’s all it’s ever been in the first place. For all of you people out there who thought Donald Trump was speaking for you by voicing your questions, it’s quite possible that his “campaign” is nothing more than viral marketing for Apprentice: Celebrity Rehab All-Stars Edition 3D. And, all of us in the media? We sadly covered it because it made you all click on us and, hey, some of it was really funny.

So, yeah, maybe we shouldn’t be surprised that some news outlets seem to be trying to keep this conspiracy on life support. It’s in their best interest. But, before you forward links to articles like the Smoking Gun piece Drudge linked to, take a look at it. Ask yourself, “Why would a news article make fun of Birthers in the first paragraph while then listing bullet point reasons why the birth certificate may be fake (yes, that’s really what the article does)?” And then ask yourself, “Am I getting journalism, or am I getting pandering?” Or maybe both?

Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • Tony the Fist

    I love the Obama pic. “This is highly illogical.”

  • perceptorii

    FOOLISH MORTALS! Your mere “physical evidence” cannot harm the alternate reality of TEH BIRFERS!

  • skyfet

    You know it will take away the livelihood of World Net Daily. At the moment they haven’t denies it but others have doubt about it. I an tell you there are more than 2 doubters, I’ve seen more.

  • timcajun

    This is why he should have never produced the long form! The nuts never go away!

  • WCinWI

    skyfet said:
    You know it will take away the livelihood of World Net Daily. At the moment they haven’t denies it but others have doubt about it. I an tell you there are more than 2 doubters, I’ve seen more.

    I’m sure you’ve been to World Net Daily more than I have so what does that say about you?

    Now pay attention to Bernanke today. That’s the real news that Obama was trying to avoid. :)

  • pinandpuller

    Act II: Ann Compton just mentioned the Social Security number.

  • Color Me Badd

    Go check out the comments on Free Republic. Talk about retarded.

  • rocky road

    Smoking gun gives several reasons why the certificate is fake. This is not going away. Obama blew it by ceding to Trump.

  • Color Me Badd

    rocky road said:
    Smoking gun gives several reasons why the certificate is fake. This is not going away. Obama blew it by ceding to Trump.

    You win the prize.

  • Thelonious Funk

    This whole matter will be cleared up when Obama finally releases the extra long form birth certificate.

    What are you hiding?

  • skyfet

    Thelonious Funk said:
    This whole matter will be cleared up when Obama finally releases the extra long form birth certificate.

    What are you hiding?

    His real Father!

  • smack

    open the .pdf file of the bc in adobe illustrator select everything then right click and release clipping mask. something is up with this thing you can see it was manipulated. this needs to be explained.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dronetek-Bulk-Vanderhuge/100000918732763 Dronetek

    Why isn’t Mediaite or the media this concerned about 9/11 truther conspiracies? Why is it that all the MSM forms together to defend Obama against any and all criticism?

  • Black and Gold Brad

    Well, it took Trump to finally do what the media refuses to — Vet Obama.

  • Barack Must Go

    To all the members of liberal Scumbagger’s grass roots movement……’ CAN I GET A RACIST or a TEABAGGER ‘ out of you regarding this article?

    This is never going to end until Obama is drummed or voted out of office and us ” real ” Americans also request to hear just how good a singing voice Michelle Obama has.

  • lane

    Two comments.

    First, all the Monica Lewinski related press conferences were MUCH more embarrasing than this one. in fact, Obama’s message and words were perfectly stated.

    Second, shouldn’t you be glad that journalistic standards are used by journalists. Unless a reporter has had some type of expert validate that the birth certificate is the real deal, isn’t it required to be carefully worded.

    Drudge is just a portal to other sources, so I wouldn’t call him a media outlet.

  • jamiec

    Oh for Pete’s sake. Please reread the Smoking Gun article — the “nutty points about the birth certificate” are exactly that; it’s pure satire.

  • cyclemadness

    The only thing wrong with this story is that none of the three cited outlets is, in fact, a news outlet. They are all propaganda outlets, and I’m surprised Mediaite mad this mistake.

  • edisciple

    What do you mean “Oh Come On!” headline? You spin this story so well yourself!

  • MPAndonee

    If you’re questioning the birth certificate, or if you’re a birther, you’re a certifiable IDIOT, and a person with a low IQ. You’re not an AMERICAN, and you don’t belong in this country.

    Furthermore, you’re transposing your hate for this president, and your racist feelings towards this president into the birth certificate situation.

    There are more important things to worry about, like an economy that has not recovered, a cabinet full of Wall street lackeys, a Guatanamo base that is still open, a Libya policy that’s a disaster, we’re going to focus on a non-issue?

    Are you people THAT stupid?

  • Nachi

    Typical of what happens to the fabric of society when the lower classes are fed lies like Donald’s.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jay-Ray/100000280184693 Jay Ray

    CNN lied on National TV just now. The father NEVER SIGNED this Certificate of Live Birth!!!!!!!!!!! How credible is CNN????? NOT.
    Also– is Obama’s Kenyan grandmother LYING when she stated in testimony that she “was present at Obama’s birth” and then stated “in Mombasa” ?? NO —
    Does CNN want to know the REAL answers ?? Why didn’t they ask the doofus reporter why the form only states the name of the hospital and does not state that the birth took place there? Also–anyone could then and even NOW, walk into a hospital with any infant, say the infant was born at home, get him checked out and receive the VERY SAME Certificate of Live Birth…………………………………that is what this is. Obama knows he was born in Kenya. Someone from Kenya WILL come forward……………..wait for it

    READ: “THE OBAMA BIRTH CERTIFICATE QUESTION” (Createspace & Amazon)

  • CAconservative

    When it takes 21/2 years to produce a legal document that should have been produced prior to his candidacy, that document does need to throughly examined.

  • justanotherconservative

    CAconservative said:

    When it takes 21/2 years to produce a legal document that should have been produced prior to his candidacy, that document does need to throughly examined.

    yes. it does need to be examined. if it’s real, why did it take so long to produce it?

  • Gorgegirl

    skyfet said:
    You know it will take away the livelihood of World Net Daily. At the moment they haven’t denies it but others have doubt about it. I an tell you there are more than 2 doubters, I’ve seen more.

    The fact is that those who are racist will never accept that a black man not only graduated with honors from Harvard, but is president of the US.

    Obviously, not believing a birth certificate put in front of your ugly face is just proof that you could be very happy wearing a KKK robe.

  • justanotherconservative

    MPAndonee said:

    Avatars by Sterling Adventures

    Jennifer Aniston and Bradley Cooper Rumors Get Recycled… Again
    Reese Witherspoon Already Buying Maternity Clothes?
    Mag Claims Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson Have Had “Last Hurrah”
    Star Magazine Apologizes to Katie Holmes for ‘Drug Shocker’ Story

    Amazon Can’t Recover All Its Cloud Data From Outage
    Life-Sized Lego Space Helmet, Where Have You Been All My Life?
    Delicious Has Been Acquired by the Founders of YouTube
    Pinhole Cameras Made Out of Hollow Eggs, Break Shell to See Picture

    WATCH: Prince Charles Breakdancing In A Double-Breasted Suit
    Franca Sozzani Is Very Much Against The ‘Damn Photoshop’
    PHOTO: Kate Moss Gets Naked, Works Hard For The Money
    Edward Enninful To Replace Alex White At W Magazine

    Stan Van Gundy Defends His Star By Asking Media To Get Whacked In The Head
    Missed Connections: 7 Instances Of Failed High Fives In Sports
    Oh Look, Rex Ryan Also Dumped On The New York Giants In His New Book
    Horrible Timing: Texas Tech Coach Questioned Obama’s Birth Certificate Last Night

    oh shut up.

  • justanotherconservative

    skyfet said:
    You know it will take away the livelihood of World Net Daily. At the moment they haven’t denies it but others have doubt about it. I an tell you there are more than 2 doubters, I’ve seen more.

    Oh my. This is a difficult one. English lesson #3: This should read: ” You know this will take away the livelihood of World Net Daily. At the moment they haven’t denied it but others have. I can tell you there are more than two doubters. I have seen more.” Your use of the English language gets more tenuous as the day wears on. Maybe too many cocktails? Or are you really just that stupid?

  • my dogs gone

    lane said:
    Drudge is just a portal to other sources, so I wouldn’t call him a media outlet.

    Drudge is a source of misinformation.
    The pictures he uses, the headlines he chooses and the articles he references all point to his bias.

  • timcajun

    More Liberty5 says:
    Like I’ve said before, Obama is no socialist – he’s a corporatist.

    …………………………………………………..
    Look at the PACs and the right will have faaaaaar more donations than Obama! They don’t like to tell that story!

  • http://endisfar.com theendisfar

    Open the Birth Certificate in Adobe Illustrator, I used CS4, and right click and ‘Remove the Clipping Mask’, you will find ten elements. This is not an original document or even a copy of an original, it is an edited PDF with the clippings available to see.

    Now even if you don’t have Ilustrator, you can see a few of the Edits. Open in Acrobat. Zoom in several times. Look at Ann’s occupation, notice ‘Non’ in the word None is a lighter color. Now look at the two typed Dates in fields 20 and 22. The both have ‘AUG – 8 196′ in lighter type than the ’1′ in 1961. In field 22 the form type “Date A”ccepted is clipped in and the 19 and the 1 in 1961 are original, the 6 is clipped in.

    Now just take a look at all the black type, form letters, and signatures, they all have white space around them from being pasted on top of the green weave background.

    Whether or not he was born here is moot to me, he is technically the bastard son of an American woman so he acquires her nationality no matter where he was born, but his need to fake his BC is troubling and deserves more attention. His Occidental and Columbia records would be another area that would shed some light.

  • http://endisfar.com theendisfar

    More Liberty5 said:
    Like I’ve said before, Obama is no socialist – he’s a corporatist.

    Socialism and Corporatism are not really all that different when you look at the two in practice. Their key similarity is Central Planning. One seeks to coerce behavior (Centrally Plan) via the market, and the other seeks control via central ownership of property and labor. Both use laws, monopolies (including labor unions), and regulations to reach there ends. The two rarely if ever exist in nature alone, they are most often blended with each other.

  • hgovernick

    justanotherconservative said:
    Oh my. This is a difficult one. English lesson #3: This should read: ” You know this will take away the livelihood of World Net Daily. At the moment they haven’t denied it but others have. I can tell you there are more than two doubters. I have seen more.” Your use of the English language gets more tenuous as the day wears on. Maybe too many cocktails? Or are you really just that stupid?

    Attack the man, rather than address the issue. Are you really just that stupid?

  • hgovernick

    Dronetek said:
    Why isn’t Mediaite or the media this concerned about 9/11 truther conspiracies? Why is it that all the MSM forms together to defend Obama against any and all criticism?

    Mediaite and all the MSM have banded together in a conspiracy to defend Obama against any and all criticism just to piss YOU off. YOU YOU YOU — it’s all about YOU — now that YOU know that, YOU can go back to sleep, where YOU spend most of your time.

  • hgovernick

    MPAndonee said:

    Are you people THAT stupid?

    Just in case you’re new here, the answer to your question is:

    YES. The birthers here are THAT stupid.

  • hgovernick

    Gorgegirl said:
    The fact is that those who are racist will never accept that a black man not only graduated with honors from Harvard, but is president of the US.

    Obviously, not believing a birth certificate put in front of your ugly face is just proof that you could be very happy wearing a KKK robe.

    Excellent observations. Right on the mark!

  • hgovernick

    More Liberty5 said:
    Mean while, Obama and his fat-cat wall street buddies are having an expensive dinner tonight.
    http://vpernet.com/browse.php?u=Oi8vd3d3Lm1vZ3VsaXRlLmNvbS9jb3J6aW5lLWJsYW5rZmVpbi1kaW1vbi1vYmFtYS1kaW5uZXIv&b=5

    Like I’ve said before, Obama is no socialist – he’s a corporatist.

    And you’re an off-topic sludge.

  • bitterclinger

    So you think birthers are stupid? At least we know that you can’t hold the highest office(or the VP) in the USA if your father owed allegiance to a foreign sovereignty. Oh wait…… it’s your Messiah sitting it the WH, rules don’t apply to him.

  • ChrisNH

    The goal is to draw Obamo’s irritability out more and more; show his petulance and immaturity. Poke and prod the small, caged animal. This is the way it should be for the next eighteen months, and I’m very pleased to declare that that it will. His life needs to be made miserable. The bonus is that his Leftist media water-carriers will also get more irritable. Their anger is my joy.

  • avoidswork

    bitterclinger said:
    So you think birthers are stupid? At least we know that you can’t hold the highest office(or the VP) in the USA if your father owed allegiance to a foreign sovereignty. Oh wait…… it’s your Messiah sitting it the WH, rules don’t apply to him.

    Yes, bitterclinger, some think Birthers are stupid. Actually, stupid is just a kind word to use when there are many more applicable.

    What’s your deal? His young white mother fell in love with a non-American black guy, married him and had his baby? Is it that it happened in the foreign and exotic land of Hawaii? That an actual birth announcement within days or so appears in local Hawaii newspapers?

    Just to recap: birthers are much more than stupid, but we’ll be kind and just give you the stupid as a moniker.

  • avoidswork

    ChrisNH said:
    The goal is to draw Obamo’s irritability out more and more; show his petulance and immaturity. Poke and prod the small, caged animal. This is the way it should be for the next eighteen months, and I’m very pleased to declare that that it will. His life needs to be made miserable. The bonus is that his Leftist media water-carriers will also get more irritable. Their anger is my joy.

    And your president being a legitimate American of mixed racial heritage is mine. Enjoy.

    Bet someone in NH is all p*ssy because his favorite racist, Haley Barbour, isn’t running for president anymore. Gonna put your money on three-times-married-but-totally-Catholic Newt?

  • Puter Boi

    “Apprentice: Celebrity Rehab All-Stars Edition 3D. ”

    They better provide free glasses….

    “Am I getting journalism, or am I getting pandering?” Or maybe both?”

    What you are getting is “journalism” via people who grew up believing that great journalism is defined by how many hits you get on your website.

  • http://endisfar.com theendisfar

    ChrisNH said:
    This is the way it should be for the next eighteen months, and I’m very pleased to declare that that it will. His life needs to be made miserable. The bonus is that his Leftist media water-carriers will also get more irritable. Their anger is my joy.

    This mortal man is a low life socialist agitator, he has earned the strife that will intermittently plague the rest of his term. This man has made the problems that Bush and Clinton propagated into mass misery for all. He will get a healthy dose of his own medicine and We the People are going to administer it.

  • Cecelia

    “the Smoking Gun piece Drudge linked to, take a look at it. Ask yourself, “Why would a news article make fun of Birthers in the first paragraph while then listing bullet point reasons why the birth certificate may be fake (yes, that’s really what the article does)?” And then ask yourself, “Am I getting journalism, or am I getting pandering?” Or maybe both?”

    Or maybe what we’re getting is the view inside Pandora’s Box.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jeff-Webber/100002288733830 Jeff Webber

    The pdf posted on whitehouse.gov is a fake. Download and open the pdf in adobe illustrator, then show the layers pallette. The layers where all the edits were done are still there. The image was never flattened.

  • CanofSand

    You use the misleading headline “Oh Come On! Some Media Outlets Already Questioning Birth Certificate Validity” (your article points to ZERO media outlets that are ACTUALLY “questioning [its] validity”), then you complain about media outlets’ headlines? Wow. Of course, you do them one worse – it’s not just your headline, but part of your actual article that repeats the lie in your headline, saying they’re “questioning it” … when they’re not. Whereas, in their actual articles, they simply state facts and if any position is taken on the birther issue, it’s one of mockery: Mocking the whole crazy sideshow that this is.

  • billwhit1357

    It is Obama’s own fault with the BC deal. He has let good military men go to prison because of his childish refusal to release it. This shows Obama has not one thread of Honor or Integrity but we have the ba$ard as our President, sickening! Ok, so he was born in America, so now we have to just face the fact that he is a horrible leader, has no idea what he is doing, has done nothing in two years that has helped America or Americans, and has proven himself to be a Liar, which America does not need in a leader. Obama is and always will be an Amature and a horrible politician because he thinks it is all about Me, the President, and not how it is supposed to be, like WE, the PEOPLE! He needs to be educated by firing his butt in 2012!

    ALLEN WEST 2012! A Proven Leader and Patriot who has served his country Honorably, something Obama has never done!

  • Barack Must Go

    How can this be an official document when there is no imprint of a foot, or in Barack’s case an ear? Also why are they not show the reverse side, couldn’t the regime afford a two sided printer?

    More questions than answers if you ask me……actually even if you don’t.

  • http://www.zazzle.com/talkingpoints NORBIT Jr.

    Where is anyone from the GOP to take on Obama the way Trump took him on?

    Not with this birth thing, but on his dysfunctional policies and power-grab.

    We’re losing Afghanistan and Pakistan; he’s got no clue on our new non-war in Libya; gas prices have more than doubled in two years; he’s nearly bankrupted the country with 4 trillion in “stimulus” and bail-outs, and little results; he’s rammed through a debacle of hidden Central Government controls over our freedom; he villifies his opponenets, and pits race and class groups against each other…

    This is what happens when the Mainstream Media SELLS-OUT, and becomes an advocate for Democratic Progressives.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jim-Treacher/542957672 Jim Treacher

    No one in the news media has ever believed anything about the Birther conspiracy except for one thing: those silly Birthers have a lot of eyes and those eyes mean traffic and ratings.

    Oh yes, the media is very discerning. Remember how they saw right through Bush’s Texas Air National Guard memos?

  • mikey970

    timcajun said:
    More Liberty5 says:
    Like I’ve said before, Obama is no socialist – he’s a corporatist.

    …………………………………………………..
    Look at the PACs and the right will have faaaaaar more donations than Obama! They don’t like to tell that story!</blo

    theendisfar said:
    Open the Birth Certificate in Adobe Illustrator, I used CS4, and right click and ‘Remove the Clipping Mask’, you will find ten elements. This is not an original document or even a copy of an original, it is an edited PDF with the clippings available to see.

    Now even if you don’t have Ilustrator, you can see a few of the Edits. Open in Acrobat. Zoom in several times. Look at Ann’s occupation, notice ‘Non’ in the word None is a lighter color. Now look at the two typed Dates in fields 20 and 22. The both have ‘AUG – 8 196′ in lighter type than the ‘1′ in 1961. In field 22 the form type “Date A”ccepted is clipped in and the 19 and the 1 in 1961 are original, the 6 is clipped in.

    Now just take a look at all the black type, form letters, and signatures, they all have white space around them from being pasted on top of the green weave background.

    Whether or not he was born here is moot to me, he is technically the bastard son of an American woman so he acquires her nationality no matter where he was born, but his need to fake his BC is troubling and deserves more attention. His Occidental and Columbia records would be another area that would shed some light.

    take your head out of you ass…this BC is exactly like mine, the black folks version…..birthers will never by satisfied….too bad……if the media covers any more of this bull shit…………….

  • VoiceofReason

    How was his dad from Kenya when British East Africa didn’t become Kenya until Dec 1963? Over 3 full years later.

    I took African history in college from a Kenyan and remember his insight into Jomo Kenyatta and post WWII strife, the battles, the Kikuyu (sp?) and the Mau Mau and I remember distincively that Kenya didn’t become Kenya until almost 1964.

    Could it be that Obama Sr. hated the Brit rule so much he refused to refer to it as their protectorate? The KAU which if IIRC gave way to Kenyatta’s KANU was formed in the mid fourties so that pre-dates the actual 1963 independence date……..so was it known to local people as Kenya (at least those fed up with Brit rule) and the person gathering info for the BC didn’t know any better?

    I know I am not the only one with a glimmer of African history knowledge and this has to come up. With the noise already beginning on the PDF “layers” I read above…..and there is bound to be more questions as the doc is scrutinized…..I wonder what will be made of this.

    I frankly don’t care where he was born……..what he is doing to this country fiscally would preclude me from supporting him if he was born in the next bed to me.

    One thing for certain…..this doesn’t seem to be going away any time soon.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Victoria-Sallese/703324932 Victoria Sallese

    ENOUGH! Will the idiots who started this stupid rumor spend their energy on curing cancer, AIDS, world hunger, and fixing the devastation from the weather? In other words, to all the stupid people who believe this shit, SHUT UP ALREADY!!!! I am sick and tired of hearing your whiny stupid pathetic voices saying the most stupid pathetic whiny things.

  • Lolwut

    VoiceofReason said:
    How was his dad from Kenya when British East Africa didn’t become Kenya until Dec 1963? Over 3 full years later. I know I am not the only one with a glimmer of African history knowledge and this has to come up. With the noise already beginning on the PDF “layers” I read above…..and there is bound to be more questions as the doc is scrutinized…..I wonder what will be made of this.

    I frankly don’t care where he was born……..what he is doing to this country fiscally would preclude me from supporting him if he was born in the next bed to me.

    One thing for certain…..this doesn’t seem to be going away any time soon.

    The only thing “for certain” is you have too much time on your hands and regardless of what you think, the government vets presidential candidates LONG before they can take office. Lets not forget that BO only has about a year left in office before his policies carry over to the next guy so they can be blamed for “f***ing everything up on the next merry go round.
    _________________________
    BTW – He’s not muslim, he’s christian, he’s half black half white, he was born an American citizen in Hawaii, and he has purple lips like a chow’s tongue.

  • Lolwut

    Victoria Sallese said:
    ENOUGH! Will the idiots who started this stupid rumor spend their energy on curing cancer, AIDS, world hunger, and fixing the devastation from the weather? In other words, to all the stupid people who believe this shit, SHUT UP ALREADY!!!! I am sick and tired of hearing your whiny stupid pathetic voices saying the most stupid pathetic whiny things.

    That’s not what entertains them. With names like “Liberal Tormenter” and “Barack must go” one can only speculate that they are here to whip people into their ideals like slave barkers and/or spend most of their time “trying” to piss people off. These forums are a pissing/spitting contest like congress. Nothing will change anytime soon. Resume obligatory /thumbs down counts.

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Self-Serve Advertising | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram