Time Really Did Not Want Obama To Be Person Of The Year, It Seems
After all of the speculation that Barack Obama was going to be Time’s Person of the Year for the second year in a row — making him the second person to win two consecutive years since Richard Nixon – the award went to … Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke. Who may not sell magazine covers, but is a defensible choice.
But, there’s more. Since announcing the pick, Time has been sending a handful of signals that seem to say that President Obama, who was announced to be a finalist for the award on Monday, really, really was not in contention after all.
First: Time Communications’ Twitter feed. See this tweet (which linked to Time’s piece on General McChrystal), and conspicuously didn’t mention Obama as a runner-up:
Ok: Twitter is Twitter. Maybe they ran out of space? But then, there’s this 1100+ word press release, which doesn’t even mention Obama’s name.
Finally, Time’s full list of runners-up and “notable people” puts Obama in #12, behind the likes of Glenn Beck and Jay Leno. What gives?
Here’s what a Time spokesperson had to say to Mediaite about the Person of the Year lists:
“The selection of Person of the Year is not a scientific process. This is a subjective choice by the editors of TIME. We consult with all of our correspondents domestically and internationally. We hear from readers on TIME.com – more than 1.3 million people voted in our online poll this year. Though this poll does NOT select the POY. The senior editors discuss the options and the managing editor makes the final decision.”
Reading between the lines: Time’s editors went out of their way to stick it to Obama, if only to defy conventional wisdom. When Time conducted a reader poll earlier this month asking who should be Person of the Year, Obama came in second, behind the Iranian protesters. Bernanke came in sixth. Of course, the poll said that “TIME’s editors reserve the right to disagree,” and they availed themselves of that right, going so far as to put Dr. Thomas Frieden (who?) ahead of the president.
Appearing on the Today Show this morning to announce the Person of the Year, Time editor Richard Stengel seemed to acknowledge the expectation that Obama would be the anointed winner by shooting him down at the start. He called Obama “not enough:” “He could be the person of the year every year, but not this year.”
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
10 comments
ChrisNH says: Whew…this should put to rest the debate on whether TIME is ‘Liberally-biased’ (roll eyes).
m says: TIME has a liberal bias they love Obama-THE MESSIAH. Part of the mainstream media cabal!!!!
Snipzor says: I seem to recall a series of right-wing posters bitching about how Time was OBVIOUSLY going to pick Obama, oh they had to pick Obama, no doubt they were going to pick them. One of their guys called him god (Apparently), of course they were going to pick him.
rmbltmbl says: Bernanke is just as terrible as Obama.. but I guess since he doesn’t have to go through a democratic process, he is worse.
TfT says: Snipzor: That was me, but I was wrong. It was Newsweek editor Evan Thomas who said:: “I mean in a way Obama’s standing above the country, above – above the world, he’s sort of God.” I got my liberal magazines mixed up.
Snipzor says: @TfT
To be honest I thought it was part of Time myself, so saying apparently was a bad way of saying “Probably, might have been someone else though, I don’t know or care”. We aren’t the first to make the mistake though, apparently.
TfT says: Too bad Glynnis already posted her moment of Glenn today; Glenn is having fun with Time’s man of the year and the other finalists.
Too bad they didn’t pick Nancy — here is her latest:
No Health Care deal this year. Nancy will work to ‘try to send House-Senate compromise to White House before State of Union’…
ImNotBlue says: Snipzor says:
December 16, 2009 at 1:54 pm
Actually… of their top 10 list… Obama made the most sense. Twitter was still a better pick… or the protesters. But since Obama has been on the cover how many other times… and since they want to continue to deny bias without ALL of the audience laughing at them, they can’t always put him on the cover.
Time almost never names the same Person of the Year twice in a row, especially if that person is President of the United States. The only exception was Nixon in 1971 and 1972 — and in ‘72 he shared the honors with Henry Kissinger. Besides Obama in 2009, this list of Presidents who *weren’t* named POY includes FDR in 1933, JFK in 1962, LBJ in 1965 and 1968, and Reagan in 1981. They’d all been POY the previous year.
- » Jon Stewart's Epic Parody Of Glenn Beck
- » CNN: Protesters Shout Racial And Gay Slurs At Lewis And Frank (Update)
- » Another CNN Anchor Fails At Celebrity Jeopardy
- » David Shuster On Media Bias, Drudge, Andrew Breitbart, And James O'Keefe
- » FAMU Sex Tape Link - Real Or Hoax?
Job hunting?
Use our proprietary jobs tool to access the largest pool of jobs aggregated from around the country.
John Boehner’s Office Selectively Edits Alcee Hasting’s ‘We Make Up The Rules’ Clip
Amid the many Internet memes that have sprung up in recent days surrounding the health care debate, a nine-second video of Alcee Hastings saying "when the deal goes down, all of this talk about rules - we make 'em up as we go along," is pretty damning evidence of the byzantine legislative process. Perhaps even more instructive, however, is the fact that the video was taken out of context. Even worse? It seems that the selective editing came from the office of Minority Leader John Bohener.
Kathy Griffin On Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell: It’s A Generational Thing
Kathy Griffin was in D.C. earlier this week for a rally at the capitol to repeal "Don't Ask, Don't Tell." While the My Life On The D List celebrity has made gay rights one of her biggest causes, she also took a moment to talk to interviewer Liz Glover about Scientology, Levi Johnston, and flying on Southwest.
More Online headlines:
»Networks Come Out In Full Force For The HCR Debate
»CNN: Protesters Shout Racial And Gay Slurs At Lewis And Frank (Update) »243
»Obama’s Final Push On Health Care To Democratic Caucus On Capitol Hill »16
»“I’m With Coco Artist” Hits Jackpot, Sort Of
»Democrats Announce They Won’t Use “Deem And Pass” »10
-
Coming soon...
© 2010 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives
| Dan Abrams, Founder
| Hosting by Datagram
| 
RSS
