why is it creepy? I was taught everything I know by an older woman. I wish it had been mariah carey. Before that twins of course. 

Will someone please check his papers?  

The original release was better. I guess these two needed some more Christmas money by re-releasing.

WANT NINTENDO 3DS. MUST BUY NINTENDO 3DS.

Seriously though, as someone who has no feelings good or bad about Bieber, his verse in this is awful. This better not become the version they play everywhere from now on.

Mariah Carey’s version of “All I Want for Christmas” has been tainted. As a female, it was one of my fave. pop holiday soundtracks for its girlie vibes.

I will not torment myself in listening to the Bieber version because I’d like my thoughts about the original to remain intact. :)

Not creepy at all. They are entertainers, remember? Not nearly as creepy or offensive as some “entertainers” promoted & approved here at Mediaite.

Beiber is not the problem, Mariah is being way creepy. This song is not provacative so she should not be barley clothed and acting provacative. The fact that she keeps facing the wall and looking back only says that she want so “done” from behind not be with her loved ones on Christmas.

Wow. On one hand, this is one of my very favorite contemporary Christmas songs and I’m too old to think that Bieber is anything more than a product of a machine stamping out teen pop sensations every couple of years. So I’m not inclined to like this to begin with. But beyond the fact that Mariah is old enough to be his grandmother, this video plays like it was not only undewritten, but actually produced by Macy’s. It barely qualifies as a video. It’s just a four-minute commercial. And a bad one at that.

But here’s the thing I find interesting: Mariah re-recorded this song last year, and you could really hear how her voice has matured. But with this video… I just replayed her original version for reference, and I don’t think she recorded tracks for the video above at all… I think they dubbed Bieber’s vocals over her original recording for a duet she didn’t actually participate in, like the duet of Unforgettable that Natalie Cole recorded “with” her father.

Mariah Carey- the owner of the biggest cheek implants on Earth.

You’ve never seen a Mariah Carey video before, have you?

let that boy cook.

Mariah Carey is hot. She’s 41 so it’s a challenge for her to look young. Bieber obviously doesn’t have to do anything to look like a teenager.

It is all very manufactured, not requiring any talent at all. 

what if you don’t think it’s creepy does that make you a creep? I didn’t see anything really wrong, the only thing I saw that was wrong was the bad acting singing together

Justin Beiber is a no-talent ass clown who will most likely be in prison by the time he’s 23.

Very, very weird.  Society is elevated more each day.

I’m not sure who I’m more disappointed with, Mariah Carey or the Biebs.  I also may have to cut up my Macy’s card.  The entire thing is just icky.  Icky, icky, icky.

LMBO……………………………..

All I want for Christmas is Mariah.

I hope the kid got to hit it.

I am absolutely perplexed as to the popularity of that little talent-and-testosterone-challenged twerp. Now, Mariah, on the other hand, is a great singer and is totally luscious. Dumb as a box of rocks, but luscious.

“beyond the fact that Mariah is old enough to be his grandmother”
Barely technically true, as it would be a very tight squeeze. Anyway: Coming soon! The alternative version they did for the upcoming -

Hustler Presents Mariah Carey and Justin Bieber Xmas with the Xmost, Starring Larry Flynt as Father Xmas, and Featuring the Full Line-up of Xmen in the All-New Xbox; non-stop Xcitement!

Possibly so – IF he does any benefits shows for the Republican Party, the Kings of Kreepy!

(Remember what the name of the Nixon 1972 election campaign was? The Committee to RE-Elect the President, that’s what – CREEP!

It’s the first MILF christmas carol!

It’s creepy because JB is in it. I mean isn’t he like 12 or something?

She should have stuck with opera; try as she might, she simply lacks sex appeal. And man, does she ever try.

In fairness, the overreliance on shots of her facing the wall is a director’s choice not hers – tho if it’s a deliberate nod to the rumored way in which the Biebs was alleged (falsely, it appears) to have gotten that groupie preggers, that’s pretty clever.

And now I wonder- is this an industry insider meme, that the Biebs kinda goes for them grabbing onto some wall?

I thought it was really nice.  Not creepy at all. I think it had a sort of store mannequin come to life sort of feel to it… 

I have an idea the kid was hoping the exact same thing.

Sex sells. Simple as that

On her booty or face? 

Its pre-teen girls’ fault that the Biebs is successful. Its no doing of his own 

Yawn….

But there are no cameo appearance shots. I”m surprised Elmo or Willie Nelson wasn’t somewhere in this. 

What happened to Beiber? Looks like a backstreet boy!

“she simply lacks sex appeal.”

I never realized you played for the other team.  Not that there’s anything wrong with that.

Yeah, every year I watch her original music vid for this song.  She was so cute.  It was perfect, no reason for this mess.. other then money.

Come on….  In the words of one of my favorite Sergeants…  ”Lighten up, Francis!”
It’s a feel-good remake.  It has some interesting vocal twists.
Must you drip venom for everything?  Sheesh…

Not the world’s best video – but hardly worth slamming – it’s just a duet with two pretty good singers

As a note – I think Mariah’s original XMAS CD was one of the best ever – but I don’t mind a remake – I still got the original

Jason, whatever you’re drinking, I owe ya one. Cheers and a hat tip, sir.

Yeah, at least in my household, “All I Want for Christmas” was an instant classic and the album has been 1 of  only 3 contemporary Xmas albums to consistently be in rotation at my family’s house every year for the last 15+ years.

If I understand correctly, this is a charity album, so the blatant commercialism is to help someone, somewhere in need…

Ouch. Okay we know that Mariah likes them young. I was struck by the irony of the song about not wanting presents juxtaposed with images of Bieber going on a shopping spree through Macy’s, then handing out swag to the huddled masses.

It was like political hypocrisy in convenient music video form.

The entire video was in my opinion a commercial. I was fairly disgusted by Mariah Carey’s “costume” touching herself, and her looking back from facing the wall with her legs spread apart while singing. What the hell was that about? Never mind, I think I know (visibly gagging)
At least Justin Bieber was fully dressed and interesting looking.

mariah carey’s constant “sexy” mugging for the camera seems really odd and inappropriate for the video, esp. considering that most of bieber’s fans are little kids.  i love her voice, i love this song, i like her big xmas earrings, i like her makeup and her smile, but otherwise, she comes off as really tasteless and a little desperate.  justin bieber, on the other hand, looked cheerful as always and age-appropriate.  mariah, take a cold shower and come back for another take! 

I am just thankful that he did something differant with his hair. Yay! Merry Christmas