1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser
Advertisement

Rachel Maddow Debunks Viral Video Showing Oil Raining In The Gulf

video
» 20 comments

The horrors of the environmental devastation in the Gulf of Mexico are very real, but, fortunately, the assault is only coming from the ground– not the sky. A YouTube video recently started making the rounds of what looked like “oil rain” falling in Louisiana, the sheen clearly visible on the ground. The problem? It’s not possible for it to rain oil– and Rachel Maddow explains why.

The video, which shows oil making rainbows on the ground as rain falls in suburban Louisiana, gained credibility in part due to suggestions that the cleanup of the ocean will be easier because the oil will evaporate over time. The simple logic of that, Maddow explains, is that what goes up must come down, causing it to rain crude from the sky. But oil doesn’t evaporate, not in its entirety, so it’s impossible for droplets of crude to be pelting us from above. Maddow guesses that what the man in the video sees is simply spilled car oil that was already on the street, but nothing new coming from the ruins of Deepwater Horizon.

Video below:

Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • lanquihue

    Actually, it’s entirely possible to rain oil after a spill, should a waterspout occur offshore.

  • Barney

    See?? This is what I was talking about with regard to the IQ’ of the typical AMessNBC viewer. Only this network would find it necessary to “debunk” the completely idiotic notion that there could actually be the phenomenon of evaporated oil-contained rain.

    …and this site congratulates Maddow for amazing bit of journalism. (sigh)

    It’s just so damned depressing that there are Americans this stupid..

    …speaking of which…did you see the video of the Milwaukee County supervisor who thought AZ was a Great Palins state or something..??

    http://voices.washingtonpost.com/postpartisan/2010/06/where_is_arizona_dont_ask_pegg.html

  • HanzoSword

    I’ve taught the water cycle to elementary school students. This is something that I taught 8 year olds – when the water evaporates, it’s clean water and nothing else. Nature’s perfect filter, it will even remove food colouring from water.

    Barney – go stick your head back in the conservative bubble you live in and allow the grown ups to talk.

  • Barney

    HanzoSword said:
    I’ve taught the water cycle to elementary school students. This is something that I taught 8 year olds – when the water evaporates, it’s clean water and nothing else. Nature’s perfect filter, it will even remove food colouring from water.

    You’ve just reinforced my point, you nitwit. This is something the average 8 year old would know

  • Cubby

    Like when Beck found it necessary to “debunk” the completely idiotic notion that FEMA was constructing death camps?

    It’s just so damned depressing that there are Americans this stupid. (I think this whenever I look at Beck’s ratings)

  • notsofast

    Yawn.

    Why is this even an article?

  • notsofast

    Why is this man talking about raining oil?

  • http://SailRabbits.com Magister

    So this explains something mentioned by Colbert on Thursday night.

    When I heard him say something about raining oil, I hadn’t seen anything about this YouTube, didn’t give it a second thought and to be honest, I hadn’t thought about the idea since, but now that I’ve seen the Maddow report and have gone back to re-view the Colbert clip, I recognize the footage.

  • valkyrie101

    Its a good idea to keep reminding the tea party right that the sky is really not falling, except allegorically.

  • notsofast

    valkyrie101 says:

    valk, would agree that RM is “da man”?

  • TfT

    So, Rachel may get some new colleagues at MSNBC. After the journalists were caught on air smashing Palin after her speech in CA yesterday, Ed Morrisey has this to say:

    “If these were opinion journalists, these comments would be no problem. If they’re news reporters expected to render an objective, fact-based report on the event, I’d say that they have a bright future at MSNBC.”

    Nice to know that MSNBC’s reputation as being non-objective, non-fact-based reporting….then they are perfect candidates for employment at MSNBC.

    Frances: Will you please put up on article about those journalists who were caught on live mic making fun of Palin? And will you please do some investigative reporting and find out who they were? Thanks in advance.

  • Geraldine Stapelton

    What about acid rain? Anyone trying to downplay the devastation of this disaster should check themselves.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jon-Martin/43100610 Jon Martin

    Oil can’t rain but it was believed that the Corexic dispersant would heat up in the gulf, changing it’s properties and allow part of the oil to evaporate.

    Oh and TFT: Sorry but people can have an opinion, even news people, those weren’t meant to go on air, just because they disagree with you doesn’t mean they should be fired. Give me a break.

  • http://SailRabbits.com Magister

    Here’s a link to a Popular Mechanics article about the video and while the scientists they contacted (including NOAA) reached a similar conclusion, I’m don’t know that I’d describe them as having as much conviction as Ms Maddow. Especially in light of the dispersant variable, @Jon mentioned in the previous comment.

  • http://SailRabbits.com Magister

    …er, and I came across the PM piece, via The Awl.

  • http://www.karlspensen.blogspot.com Karl Spensen

    Speaking of MR. Maddow — happy GAY PRIDE week everyone!!1 Check out these AWESOME comments by the Fox Faithful on my FAVORITE website of all time, FOX NATION (The Most Powerful Name in News Websites!!1)!!1

    http://www.thefoxnation.com/culture/2010/06/25/10-year-old-named-grand-marshal-gay-pride-parade

    “It’s time for the good Lord to open up another Sodom and Gomorrah and burn these perverts off the face of the earth!”
    “Gays. What a joke. Hijacking a perfectly good word.”
    “They prey on the young. Homosexuality is a sin that if left as is continues to corrupt and leads to dark things. ”
    “The gay and Liberal community want to strart our kids to be gay while they are young.”
    FOX VIEWERS ARE THE MOST WELL-INFORMED PEOPLE IN OUR ONCE PROUD REPUBLIC!!1

  • notsofast

    Karl, I heard you got raped and when the police asked if you could describe your attacker, you said, “Are you crazy? Do you think I have eyes in the back of my head?”

  • notsofast

    RM, that was not oil, it was the stain of the union workers down in the gulf!

  • JohnSimpson

    Is she is on?

  • http://www.jessicadances.com/eyecons Jessica

    Alrighty then Rachel debunk this: Meet Kindra

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iVShXDsGD0I This Venice LA local has been granted full security clearance… has seen the disaster from every possible angle and is NOT impressed.

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram