1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser
Advertisement

Rachel Maddow And Jon Stewart Discuss Hyperbole, Guns And McVeigh

video
» 68 comments

Last night Jon Stewart had Rachel Maddow as a guest on his show — sort of the Liberal equivalent to when Palin shows up on Beck — to talk about her upcoming special on the McVeigh tapes. The tapes have apparently never been heard before, and a “boiled down” version of a series of interviews that McVeigh did after being convicted of the Oklahoma City Bombings while he was on Death Row.

Maddow says it is clear from the tapes that McVeigh felt the bombings had the intended outcome and felt “triumphant.” Interestingly, considering these are two fairly charismatic media folk, the interview didn’t provide much humor or levity. Except perhaps for the part where Maddow announced that, if given the opportunity, she “could kill bin Laden with a spoon.”

The closest Maddow got to connecting McVeigh’s anti-government stance with the Tea Partiers was to say that the country is currently “experiencing and upswing again in sort of anti-government extremism, and that’s not to say the next Timothy McVeigh is out there, but it is to say that people should not be encouraging government…violence against government institutions and people.” Interestingly, it was Stewart who dialed back the comparison cautioning that while rhetoric is important “you can’t legislate or be to the lowest common or craziest denominator among us” i.e. only actual crazy people are set off by extreme language…the rest of us know better. Video below.




Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • valkyrie101

    It is inappropriate to blame the tea party for violence, since it has not been violent. However, the tea party needs to renounce violence, to discourage threats of violence coming from the tea party faithful, vis a vis the signs that some tea party members carry threatening violence.

  • valkyrie101

    Fox news seems to be getting this anti-violence message: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/04/13/fox-news-publishes-semi-c_n_535539.html

  • m

    I actually fear the American Taliban. Anti-governmentalism is an extremist ideology. Hopefully sooner or later, because most of these people are really old, they will die out and leave room for the younger generations.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Susie-Credeur/728333708 Susie Credeur

    Fifteen years after Oklahoma City, we can see that home grown terrorists in the vein of McVeigh are few and far between. There are isolated incidents but nothing organized– kind of along the line of “lone assassin”. A NYT article not too long ago observed that even with all the mouthing off and political dissent, nothing violent comes of it. It’s just that–mouthing off.

  • Barney

    I would like to have seen Timothy McVeigh re-animated and put to death over and over for each individual he murdered.

    I would also like to see justice on behalf of the 76 men, women, and children burned alive at Waco by Clinton, Reno, and Wesley Clark.

    They murdered 76 people. Why are they still walking around free?

  • The Real Royal King

    Anti-governmentalism is, in its purist form, anarchy. To be sure, the Tea Partiers and the militia members are not anarchists. In point of fact, they seem to espouse a high level of governmental intervention in foreign policy and in internal social policy. One of the greatest falsehoods about the Tea Partiers is that they are libertarian in their views. Far from it. That makes them conflicted, but no less a potential threat. I watched Stewart and Maddow, and I don’t think they were pushing for an equivalency, but for an understanding of McVeigh. I am sure we all hope that McVeighism is sui generis and that Tea Partyism is as well, that Tea Partyism is not a slippery slope into McVeigism. To that end, I do think Tea Partiers and conservatives in general ought to clear in their denunciation of rightist terrorism, not the wink-wink, nod-nod, too cute by half type of Palin and Bachmann response.

  • The Real Royal King

    I won’t argue with you, Barney With the Highly Offensive Avatar, other than to say in your denunciation of Reno & Company, let’s not exhalt Koresh, a violent, dangerous cultist who routinely physically, sexually and physically abused women and children and engaged in the most sordid perverse, deviant, anti-social behavior. Nor should we diminish his crazed followers.

  • valkyrie101

    We all looked on in horror at the Waco tragedy. And though most of us did not feel sorry for Koresh, we did feel sorry for the children that were burned alive. The government most definitely screwed up with that. Government abuse is a problem that we should be concerned about. However, by peaceful and democratic means.

  • Big_F-ing_Deal

    I for one am rather uncomfortable with all the promotions MSNBC is doing for that special. I’m sick of it.
    It’s terror-porn disguised as a public service.
    A few well placed ads would be far better than the blanket advertising they have been doing to raise their ratings on the back of a mass murderer.
    And now Rachel is doing the “talk show circuit” to promote it as well?

    It’s overkill (no pun intended).

  • The Real Royal King

    I agree with you, Valkyrie.

    We would have been better served by a more aggressive post-event investigation.

    I had hoped that Texas’ Child Protective Services would have examined its policies as well and been more aggressive in protecting children whose parents knowingly and intentionally placed them in dangerous, abusive, cult situations. Unfortunately, that didn’t happen either.

    We seem to have learned little and changed less. I suppose the only blessing is that the world does not have to deal with Koresh and his crazed followers anymore.

  • The Real Royal King

    I think your point is awfully good, Big. In fact, I think it may be the best post of the week.

  • roxsteady

    Waco is a stark warning to these militia lunatics. The US Military will blow the crazies off this planet. They were warned repeatedly. And Rachel is just terrific!

  • MarkStr82Hell

    Big_F-ing_Deal says:
    April 14, 2010 at 10:08 am
    I for one am rather uncomfortable with all the promotions MSNBC is doing for that special. I’m sick of it.
    It’s terror-porn disguised as a public service.
    A few well placed ads would be far better than the blanket advertising they have been doing to raise their ratings on the back of a mass murderer.
    And now Rachel is doing the “talk show circuit” to promote it as well?

    It’s overkill (no pun intended).

    Wow, Who would have thought I completely agree with this individual. Well said. It’s similar to MSNBC’s obsession with thugs in the prison system (Lock-Up) and Pedophiles (CAP). Is there nothing positive
    to report?

  • felixw

    Tim McVeigh executed in 2001

    First tea party in 2009

    Rachel must be running out of tea party smears if she needs to reach for these tenuous connections. Maybe next week she can link the tea partiers to Marie Antoinette or Rasputin.

  • roxsteady

    By the way, I don’t think it’s overkill. You’re not forced to watch it. I’m sure the teabaggers aren’t thrilled because the rhetoric they spew sounds exactly the same as that nut job’s. Not to mention the rally that these gun loving idiots are holding on the anniversary of the Oklahoma City bombing. Very classy. The government is not coming for their guns and they know it. They simply want to flaunt their weapons for us all. The problem is that, as I said, no one has more fire power than the US Military. These loons who can’t get their way by voting, since the sane people out number them, have chosen to try and intimidate the rest of us. It’s not working. They’re just reminding us of recent history.

  • The Real Royal King

    Well, Felix, you can certainly see an ideological continuity in McVeigh and the Tea Partiers’ anti-government positions. Of course, that is terribly broad and of little value. Also, McVeigh was mild-mannered but dangerous, and the Tea Partiers are loud and obnoxious, but toothless. I don’t think Rachel was making a direct line connection. I believe she was saying there is renewed interest in McVeigh because of the emergence of anti-government groups, all the way from the militia groups, particularly in Michigan and Oklahoma, to the Tea Partiers. To that extent, I think Rachel is correct.

    Rasputin, I can see. Marie?

  • roxsteady

    The baggers are a bunch of ignorant racists. I’ve explained this before. They’ve received a tax cut when Obama took office. None of these inbreds makes more than 250,000 dollars a year. Under Regan and Bush, the government was never small yet, where were these idiots? Regan trippled the deficit and Bush nearly trippled it. They seem to have a protest every week now and it’s gotten old. Even that idiot pin up isn’t stupid enough to be seen with these loons. Did you notice how quiet the latest recess was? They’re basically a national joke.

  • roxsteady

    By the way, Oklahoma highschool students couldn’t answer the question, who was the first President of the United States. You would think their states had more important things to do! They’re breeding the stupid.

  • Penguin60

    Denunciation as an entirety is breeding stupid. No hate in the those posts. “inbreds”? What a tragedy.

  • ex politicalmedia hack

    Could a person be more disgusting than this “roxsteady” person?

    oh – hes explained this all before huh?

    inbreds?

    and people who make less than $250,000 a year are somehow…what..bad? stupid?

    And this fool pretends that he is a progressive that stands up for “working americans”?

    His reference to Oklahoma students is beyond stupid….and even though Im a labor/leftist – I am disgusted by anyone who uses the word “teabaggers” to insult the new right wing. Its childish and disgraceful – which seems to be this “person’s” M.O. in all things.

  • The Real Royal King

    My fellow Texans and I always take great solace in the fact that Oklahoma neighbors us. It’s rather like the small town beauty queen whose best friend is inevitably fat with frizzy hair, bad teeth and pimples. How beautiful the queen looks standing next to her.

  • felixw

    According to a poll published today:

    “Twenty-four percent (24%) of voters now consider themselves a part of the Tea Party movement, an eight-point increase from a month ago. Another 10% say they are not a part of the movement but have close friends or family members who are.”

    That means a hundred million people are either planning to bomb Federal buildings or are harboring criminals in their home. I hope Rachel reports on this highly dangerous situation tonight.

  • timzank

    roxsteady says:
    April 14, 2010 at 10:40 am
    By the way, Oklahoma highschool students couldn’t answer the question, who was the first President of the United States. You would think their states had more important things to do! They’re breeding the stupid.

    Ask that same question in any NYC public school and see what the results are.

  • The Real Royal King

    Yes, Felix, and one point in time substantial numbers of Americans were members of Bull Moose Party, the Margarine Producers Association and the Arthur Godfrey Fan Club.

  • Olby Sucks

    Why is maddow so infactuated with mcveigh, but, totally ignored recent terorrism attacks by hasan, fort dix 6, etc? Answer, it’s a partisan hack!

  • Penguin60

    The obligatory marginalizing statement.

  • Penguin60

    Not you Olby.

  • Olby Sucks

    I know who you are referring to, penguin60. The olbyloon diversion @ 11:14.

  • Barney

    “The Real Royal King says:
    April 14, 2010 at 9:31 am
    I won’t argue with you, Barney With the Highly Offensive Avatar, other than to say in your denunciation of Reno & Company, let’s not exhalt Koresh, a violent, dangerous cultist who routinely physically, sexually and physically abused women and children and engaged in the most sordid perverse, deviant, anti-social behavior. Nor should we diminish his crazed ..”

    Huh? Why is my avatar offensive?/ You don’t like pictures of black people, you racist a-hole??

    So..where is the proof behind ANY allegation of abuse, sexual or otherwise, by Koresh?. Who in the hell is “exhalting” anyone.

    Clinton, Reno, and Wesley Clark should face the same punishment that McVeigh did.

    Because individuals were practiicing their right to live as they pleased, you think they’re “crazed”? And, it was OK to murder them by burning them alive?

  • The Real Royal King

    I’m not sure what “infactuated” means, perhaps, full of facts. Mr. Wizard? And, why is it you would single out Mr. Wizard for scorn and ridicule.

    Might I ask, Jeff, do you have proof that Ms. Maddow “totally ignored” Fort Hood and Fort Dix? If you Google “Maddow Fort Hood” you quickly get more than 50 pages of Maddow talking about Fort Hood or people talking about Maddow talking about Fort Hood. As to Fort Dix, there 43 web pages which deal with Maddow and the topic. I am sure you will recall that the Fort Dix indictments were in May 2007, and Rachel did not get her show until August 2008.

    So your point seems wholly incorrect, Jeff. Do you care to explain why you are wrong on this point. Is it intentional or just an example of sloppy grunting on your part?

    We have left on the table the question of all your incorrect predictions about the 2008 presidential election, President Obama’s swearing in and the CAIR lawsuit. Amerika wants to know the answers to these questions. Basically, Amerika wants to know how you could have been so consistently and thoroughly wrong. We await your answer.

    While you are in the question answering mode: Why are you so “infactuated” with Olbermann?

  • The Real Royal King

    Many thanks Barney With the Highly Offensive Avatar. You effectively made my point.

  • Barney

    “Many thanks Barney With the Highly Offensive Avatar. You effectively made my point.”

    Huh?? Seriously..what do you find offensive about the FLOTUS?? Do you hate black people?? If so, would it be OK to murder them in youir view, since you have very strange rationale for the government being able to kill without impunity anyone it chooses?/

  • valkyrie101

    felix,
    The tea party brings on tea party scorn when it permits or endorses violent signs or language. Of course the tea party can not control its demonstrators. But at least publically, as a matter of stated tea party principle, violence must be renounced. Not with a wink and a nod.

  • Barney

    I find your screen name and crown avatar highly offensive since monarchies historically had murdered whomever they wished to without impunity as they considered themselves above the masses

  • valkyrie101

    I suppose if someone were to view Waco as essentially a second amendment dispute, then it was somewhat of an Alamo.

  • Olby Sucks

    Karesh didn’t “rape” anybody. Totally made up by reno and her klub.

  • Olby Sucks

    The only time maddow brought up fort dix or hasan was to downplay the events.

  • The Real Royal King

    Olby Sucks says:
    April 14, 2010 at 12:08 pm

    The only time maddow brought up fort dix or hasan was to downplay the events.

    Wrong, again. You’re not reading or watching the discussions.

  • The Real Royal King

    Olby Sucks says:
    April 14, 2010 at 12:06 pm

    Karesh didn’t “rape” anybody. Totally made up by reno and her klub.

    Wrong, again, Jeff.

    The raid, explosion and fires were precipitated by efforts to serve an arrest warrant for abuse of minor girls and weapons charges. After the tragedy, abuse victims testified as to being raped before Congress. There is some compelling, sobering testimony of the abused girls which you can find readily using virtually any search engine.

    To be sure, Koresh wasn’t convicted, but only because he effectively killed himself. In that sense, he wasn’t found guilty, but that would be rather like the Menendez brothers seeking leniency because they were orphans.

    How very odd that one would defend the despicable Koresh.

    You need t do some reading, Jeff. You are drowning in a sea of ignorance.

  • Olby Sucks

    philby/robert, you’re a liar.

  • valkyrie101

    Olby, when you have sex with twelve year olds, that is rape. And his own ex-members say that he did.

  • Olby Sucks

    Maddow Complains Labeling Hasan Terrorist’ Would Paint the Democrats as Soft on Terror’ … She even attempted to make the case on Hasan’s behalf against a terrorism label. …

  • Olby Sucks

    MADDOW: We begin tonight with another deadly act of domestic terrorism.

    As Maddow said this, a photo of Tiller was shown situated above the word TERRORISM in capitalized block letters, lest anyone miss the point.

  • The Real Royal King

    Jeff seems to be copying and pasting anything he can find, however senseless or irrelevant.

    Might I recommend that you make yourself a nice mug of Bosco and snuggle up with a comforter?

  • Olby Sucks

    philby/robert/mark plays the “you’re just copying and pasting” card…LOL!

  • Barney

    Clinton, Reno, and Wesley Clark burned 76 men, women, and children alive..

    …and this idiot The Real Royal King is defending this based on false testimony of a girl named Kiki Jewell, who is documented to have lied constantly on her stories about the Branch Davidians..

    ..she was put up by the thugs that murdered the 76 men, women, and children

  • valkyrie101

    The left had radical and violent groups in its midst back in the sixties and early seventies. Those forces did not suceed in bringing the left to violent revolution. The mainstream left, the non-violent protester, reigned in the violent element. Likewise, among the tea partiers are some people who are gathering weapons and threatening violence. It is the tea party’s job to disavow violence, or action outside of the democratic process.

  • Munch

    Maddow Complains Labeling Hasan Terrorist’ Would Paint the Democrats as Soft on Terror’”

    Well, duh? The Christmas bomber was an “isolated incident” in their minds and they couldn’t get him an attorney fast enough.

  • Penguin60

    I wonder when RM is going to do an expose on home grown Islamic terrorists? I won’t be holding my breath. In recent times who have killed more, homegrown Islamic terrorists or militia? I wonder how a poll would come out if you asked the question:
    Who concerns you more, TEA Party members or homegrown Islamic Terror?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Brian-Rogiers/1426705964 Brian Rogiers

    When will the left “reign” in the Earth Liberation Front? Ever see footage of the G20 or WTO protests? How many were wounded at the last Tea Party protest? How many were arrested? What was the cost of property damage?

    Those who pay attention know that the left simply wants to paint the Tea Party as racist, violent, uneducated hillbillies so the average Independent will think twice about showing support. It’s not working, and the more they smear, the more support the Tea Party gets.

    Dissention is patriotism, remember? Or is that only when the left dissents?

  • The Real Royal King

    Yes, Barney, you are clearly establishing your reputation around here. DNA testing established that Koresh fathered 12 children by “women” age 13 or under. That, Sir, even by our lenient standards in Texas, is rape.

  • The Real Royal King

    Penguin, Brian: Why are you so fearful of a McVeigh expose? What does that do to you?

  • The Real Royal King

    The Bosco is finished and the comforter is stinky. And, now, Jeff, you have a number of important outstanding questions to answer. Please proceed.

  • Penguin60

    I really have no fear of bringing up that coward. He was a criminal and got what he deserved. I will wait and see how RM plays it. I hope she does not try to link McVeigh and the TEA Party. She, and others, have asserted the TEA Party people advocate violence. How many of these people have actually been to a TEA Party event? I have, and not seen anything close to violence. There was a counter protest at one of the gatherings and even that was handled quite well, nobody said a word to them. I have never been politically active (except for voting). I see many others that are exercising their 1st Amendment Rights having to defend themselves for doing so, and I think that’s a tragedy.

  • ImNotBlue

    valkyrie101 says:
    April 14, 2010 at 9:14 am

    You see (and probably have recognized) the catch-22 in the situation. IF the Tea Party says to its members, “Don’t be violent,” the media will report (read: regurgitate from left-wing websites) the, “If they weren’t already violent, they wouldn’t have had to say anything,” line. IF they don’t say anything, then the media (again) will say, “The need to do XYZ!” Either way, the left and the media play “Gotcha!”

    Frankly, it’s just another political tactic… but watch how the band of regulars gobble it up.

    The Real Royal King says:
    April 14, 2010 at 9:31 am

    Why is “Barney’s” avatar offensive?

    roxsteady says:
    April 14, 2010 at 10:31 am

    By the way, I don’t think it’s overkill. You’re not forced to watch it.

    Yes, this is your approach to Beck, Hannity, O’Reilly, Limbaugh, FOX News, etc. etc. Right?

    OH wait… no it’s not.

  • TylerDurdin

    TRRK, would you please call someone a racist; it’s been one minute. You are behind your daily quota.

  • Jamestaylor

    Give him a minute. hahaha

  • The Real Royal King

    I will wait and see how RM plays it.

    That’s a good decision.

  • The Real Royal King

    The Real Royal King says:
    April 14, 2010 at 9:31 am

    Why is “Barney’s” avatar offensive?

    Let’s get real. I am not going to discuss that in what is suppose to be a civil forum.

    I suppose you don’t think the “Little Rascals” has racist overtones.

  • Penguin60

    “That’s a good decision.”
    Thanks.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dg29GWk2nMc&playnext_from=TL&videos=037c9kQKGCg&feature=sub

    I know this is Maxine, but it points out perceptions are real.
    How do you counter this logic?

  • ImNotBlue

    The Real Royal King says:
    April 14, 2010 at 3:44 pm

    Ah… the old, “I’ll call you a racist, but won’t talk about why” canard. Got it.

    How about this… I think your avatar is sexist and anti-Semitic. Go ahead, ask me why… shhhh, I’ll never tell!

    As for the “Little Rascals,” you mean the show or a comment? I don’t think I’ve ever seen the show, and I’m not sure who made the comment.

  • felixw

    This “narrative” about violent Republicans has reached a point of absurdity when the Left needs to drudge out events from Waco and Oklahoma from the last century to distract attention from what is really happening right now with the Obama administration.

    The plain truth is that the tea parties have been organized because the government is heading towards bankruptcy. Maddow and company can spin their “narrative” all day long, but they can’t change the reality. The tea parties are about policy not skin color or birth certificates or blowing up buildings. The fact that the left is absolutely unwilling to discuss and debate these policies, and constantly need to “re-frame” the discussion to avoid all policy discussion, tells you how desperate they have become.

  • http://www.thecobraslair.com Cobra

    I guess folks aren’t up on current events.

    From Associated Press:

    “A federal grand jury in Detroit has indicted nine people, including Kristopher Sickles, in connection with an alleged plot to kill police and start an anti-government revolution. All are in custody.

    Prosecutors said the group, calling itself the Hutaree militia, was led by southern Michigan resident David Stone, and members planned to commit an act of violence that would draw a large police response, then attack the officers.

    They are charged with seditious conspiracy, or plotting to levy war against the U.S., and attempting to use weapons of mass destruction.

    On March 27, federal agents searched the defendants’ homes in Michigan, Ohio and Indiana. Authorities recovered hand grenade instructions and schematics, a container of potassium chlorate, drugs, weapons, gas masks and a book of Adolf Hitler’s speeches during raids of members’ homes last month, according to search warrant records.

    At the Sickles’ small, yellow-and-white mobile home, investigators said they found 13 guns, more than 8,000 rounds of ammunition, a Hutaree uniform, a “ghillie suit” used by snipers to hide in the woods and a bulletproof vest.

    Sickles, 27, traveled to Michigan five times to train with the Hutaree, prosecutors wrote in a court document filed Tuesday. They wrote that at one of the trainings, in January, he said he wanted to set off a homemade bomb outside the Huron, Ohio, Police Department. In February, they said, he offered to martyr himself in a “suicide by cop,” taking as many officers with him as he could.”

    From Cleveland Plain Dealer Wire Services:

    “The number of extremist anti-government groups and militias grew from 149 in 2008 to 512 in 2009, said Heidi Beirich, director of research at the Southern Poverty Law Center, a civil groups that monitors extremism.”

    I think there’s NO BETTER TIME than NOW to air the Timothy McVeigh tapes and closely examine the militia movement’s rise. It’s a shameful dilemna this nation finds itself in, when we WAIT for tragedies to occur, instead of learning from the PAST in attempts to avert them.

    –Cobra

  • Penguin60

    Shining a light on these cockaroaches is a great idea, but don’t forget these are not the only deviants that want to destroy the USA.
    Linking these miscreants to Americans peacefully exercising their 1st Amendment rights is a political tool that further divides us as a Nation.

    Learning from the past? Let’s point that finger at radical Islam also.
    Review the You tube above, “dangerous rhetoric” or Americans exercising their 1st Amendment Rights?
    Unfortunately it seems to depend on the little letter after one’s name.

  • http://www.thecobraslair.com Cobra

    Penguin,

    You understand that there have been THOUSANDS of detainments and deportations of Muslims from the United States in the past decade, right? My point is that Muslims aren’t the ONLY folks capable of violent extremism. There are plenty of home grown domestic threats with no ties to Islam. Many of them use the CROSS as their symbol…iron, celtic or burning.

    –Cobra

  • Penguin60

    I’m sure there are other elements out there that we have no idea about. I agree the Cross can be perverted as any other symbol.

  • lihaoxj16

    Buy full line Juicy couture products from our site at a low price to make yourself a fashionista! Dress juicy couture clothing, holding juicy couture
    Shop prom dresses, formal dresses, prom shoes, 2010 designer prom gowns at dres4sale.
    for cocktail dresses, dresses for prom, homecoming dresses, and evening dresses. Cheap prom dresses or couture designer evening gowns for your next formal.
    evening dresses
    Evening Dresses. Women’s Formal & Special Occasion Dresses … Welcome to Cheap Evening Dresses for Sale! … Buy Cheap Evening Dresses Sales & Accessories
    prom dresses

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dwight-Gibler/1311965348 Dwight Gibler

    this ruins my theory that no one watches MSNBC- but I am still happy. I didn’t waste my time watching under achievers gloat and aimlessly point fingers at others.When they leave the room does the average IQ jump., or is that just an optical allusion…

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram