1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser
Advertisement

Poll: Should Helen Thomas’ Nameplate Be Removed From Her Press Seat?

poll
» 24 comments

The Helen Thomas controversy rages on. Less than a week after a video of the legendary White House correspondent saying she thought the Jews should “get the hell out of Palestine” and go back to Germany and Poland (her sisters now say she was misinterpreted) went viral the debate has now turned from who will get Thomas’ much coveted White House press briefing room seat to whether the “Helen Thomas” nameplate on the seat should be removed.

As Tommy Christopher reported yesterday, word has it that (much to the consternation of Media Matters) Fox News’ Major Garrett — who, it’s worth noting, has always been among the journalists at Fox News who the White House has not had issues with — is the top contender for the prime seat. The question now is, once the seat has been filled should the nameplate remain? NPR’s Alicia Shepard thinks yes.

Give away her coveted seat. Some other news organization deserves it.

But don’t take down the name plate that honors the most famous female journalist ever to cover 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. And the rest of us should not allow one ill-conceived remark to make us forget the accomplishments of a genuine journalistic pioneer.

Politico reports that sentiment aside, the plate will likely go: “One White House reporter told me yesterday that this is not likely, however, and expects it to be gone, saying that “it’s not like it’s going to be there forever.”" Tommy, meanwhile, tells me that “several of us talked about Helen’s nameplate yesterday, and what a valuable piece of history it would be. If temperatures cool sufficiently, the nameplate could be displayed on a plaque in the briefing room, or perhaps at the WHCA.”

What do you think?


Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • marigrace

    Get rid of the name plate. She is a disgrace and a bigot.

    .

  • JohnSimpson

    Of course! She is a bigot!

  • Burnnotice

    No, you don’t Remove it. You leave it as a reminder of the past. That is the problem now. Progressives quickly remove any reminders of the past so future generations will be led to believe in lies, instead of the truth.

  • sarainitaly

    I would take it off. What if a Jewish person gets that seat? Do they want to sit in her seat?

    Give the plaque to Tommy. He was the ones who asked Gibbs about her comments, he should get her plaque if he wants it.

  • ice queen

    Remove the seat, send it to the Smithsonian and get a new chair.

  • sarainitaly

    Did she sit in that seat for all of her 50 years? How long was that her seat?

  • sarainitaly

    ice queen says:
    June 10, 2010 at 11:09 am

    that’s a good idea.

    i would put an asterisks on it though. haha

  • Liberty – Not Redistribution

    It’s not her seat. It’s in the White House Press room. The US Taxpayer owns that seat, not some old bigot.

  • http://twitter.com/SailRabbits Magister

    I was going to suggest that the poll should’ve used a third or maybe a fourth option — one where the nameplate was moved to another location or possibly given to Helen for her university archives (I assume someone will eventually get her papers) — but then I read ice queen’s suggestion and that too sounds like a good idea.

  • Android Simulacrum

    Helen Thomas has been a national treasure and served the American people for decades. She has done more for our nation and the world than probably any of the sanctimonious twits castigating her for one stupid statement. Besides, why should her personal opinions be relevant? She is the complete professional.

  • wolfytoo

    My god, spare me…Helen Thomas has had a long, illustrious career….How many in your life time have you not said something you regret…”people in glass houses…etc.”

    And, in terms of her remarks that Israel should withdraw from occupied lands, right on, Helen. In 1967 the UN gave Israel two resolutions relating to occupying its own territory. Since then it continues to blatantly ignore these resolutions. Because the US is so terrified of “upsetting” Israel and because the US is a terrorist state like Israel it has never backed the resolutions. The US and Israel abide by the UN only when it serves their purpose and continue to be aggressor, immoral, unethical and criminal states.

    I think Helen’s career has been courageous. She has pressed presidents to answer challenging questions. She has been adamant in her philosophy for the world and its leaders to do right. She now made a mistake, that in her advancing years, she regrets. Give her a break and all of you get off your moral high ground.

  • Liberty – Not Redistribution

    Android Simulacrum says:
    “She is the complete professional.”

    Yeah a professional bigot.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jim-Treacher/542957672 Jim Treacher

    I’m sure they can find a place for her nameplate in the Holocaust Museum.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Steve-Morris/100000030656934 Steve Morris

    The seat belongs to the American People and should have never had her name on it in the first place.

    Who new her name was on it? Who doesn’t give the front seat to little old ladies?

  • Snipzor

    Since when did Israel=Jewish? Get off your moral high ground people, you obviously contribute nothing by making vague generalizations of the entire topic.

    Anyways, the name stays, especially considering how damn long she’s been doing it, as well as how damn good she was at her job.

  • sarainitaly

    Snipzor says:
    June 10, 2010 at 2:21 pm
    Since when did Israel=Jewish?

    When she told Jews to get the hell out of Israel.

  • WindShieldWipers

    You know, she said some stuff, the Rabbi said some stuff, but why is it always black or white??

    I really liked this guy’s take on it:

    http://www.entertainmedaily.com/2010/06/helen-thomas-deserves-a-punch-in-the-face-but-rabbi-david-nesenoff-should-be-kicked-in-the-balls/

    What do you guys think?

  • Nachi

    Absolutely not. (See the little hate-mongers here complaining!) Unable to connect between “Jews” and “Iraelis.”

  • The Real Royal King

    sarainitaly says:
    June 10, 2010 at 2:32 pm
    Snipzor says:
    June 10, 2010 at 2:21 pm
    Since when did Israel=Jewish?

    When she told Jews to get the hell out of Israel.

    Not that honesty seems to be relevant, but she told the Jews to get out of Palestine.

  • rooti

    Helen Thomas told the truth and has always asked the hard questions. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a fool.

  • socrates

    I am an antisemite. I was not always thus. I began to change about two years ago when I learned of the USS Liberty. Then, in short order, I began to notice the way that the mainstream media covered stories related to Israel. There followed the shock that came as I learned of dual citizenship among our leaders and all that that implied. As I became more and more aware, things began to snowball. The attack upon the unarmed convoy and the mauling of the last of our great journalists is just more of the pattern.

    I am an antisemite by the definition that the backers of Israel insist on. They created me so that they could use me to frighten the Jew just as they use the Jew as a human shield. I cannot reach them there. Only Jewry itself can do that. They have failed to do so many times in the past, but things change. Things change.

  • upthezog

    Not only should they remove the nameplate, but the states should clean up Gaza so Israel can fill it with casinos and turn it into the Las Vegas of Eurasia. Tehran should also be nuked for Ahmadinejad’s persistent insolence.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Zon-Moy/1319772848 Zon Moy

    How about removing the nameplates of all the rest of the media hacks, use the Rico laws to destroy the rotten media giants as hopelessly corrupt organizations along with both the democratic and republican crime families. then put her nameplate in a place of honor as the only slightly honest media person out there.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Alma-Terry-Robinson/1390350842 Alma Terry Robinson

    The woman’s career is not tarnished even tho she said what many of us is thinking. She realizes that Israel is basicallly wanting to eradicate the people they displaced. Doesn’t their own history

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram