»» Columnists

Janet Napolitano on This Week: The System Worked ‘Like Clockwork’


video

peppard

Jake Tapper interviewed DHS Secretary Janet Napolitano on ABC’s This Week, giving an early indicator of what the administration’s narrative on Flight 523 will be. Caught between the need to reassure a jumpy public, political opponents drooling at the chance to score points, and an unwillingness to tip our hand to those who would do us harm, Napolitano had her work cut out for her. Even given those factors, the Secretary’s overarching message was tone deaf, to say the least.

Napolitano sold the notion that the system worked, hitting the talking point several times:

I think the important thing to recognize here is that once this incident occurred, everything happened that should have. The passengers reacted correctly, the crew reacted correctly, within an hour to 90 minutes, all 128 flights in the air had been notified. And those flights already had taken mitigation measures on the off-chance that there was somebody else also flying with some sort of destructive intent.

So the system has worked really very, very smoothly over the course of the past several days.

Tapper followed up by saying “(Y)ou keep saying everybody acted the way they were supposed to. Clearly the passengers and the crew of that Northwest Airlines flight did. But I think there are questions about whether everybody in the U.S. government did.”

Napolitano was undeterred:

Now once this incident occurred, everything went according to clockwork. Not only sharing throughout the air industry, but also sharing with state and local law enforcement, products were going out on Christmas Day, they went out yesterday, and also to the industry to make sure that the traveling public remains safe.

So, a man on a really long terrorism list carries an incendiary device onto an airplane, ignites it in midair, the detonator fails, the passengers jump the flame-crotched suspect, and he is subdued/extinguished. As Hannibal Smith would say, “I love it when a plan comes together.” Maybe she meant to say that it worked like “A Clockwork Orange.”

In fairness, that’s not exactly what Napolitano said, but that’s the effect. She prefaced it all by saying “Once this incident occurred,” which is a lot like bragging about how well Trojans work after your girlfriend is pregnant.

Tapper interviewed Press Secretary Robert Gibbs next, and he wisely abandoned Napolitano’s breathtakingly clueless line.

Here’s the clip:

EmailTwitterFacebookDiggRedditStumble UponYahoo BuzzLinkedInTumblrDelicious


17 comments

  • MMcFM MMcFM says:

    Considering the President’s obfuscation of Major Hasan’s terrorist action at Fort Hood, his West Point Afghanistan speech which revealed a lack of conviction for victory as the objective in exchange for the lives of our sons, daughters, brothers, sisters, fathers and mothers; and his lack of interest in a Terrorist on flight 523, I have to conclude that the President tacitly supports Muslim terrorism and doesn’t really see it as a problem within our government, our national security, or our international interest. President Obama clearly choses not to protect the nation by making strong public statements against terrorist actions when they happen.

    And Michael Moore had the audacity to criticize Bush in the first minutes on 9/11 — we’ve got a President that can’t get it right for days, weeks, and months.

  • Bill Adkins says:

    It may be that Napolitano has proven the Peter Principle and has been promoted to the level of his incompetence. It happens. George W. Bush proved it when he was elected Governor of Texas then again as President. Eight years in the Oval Office and he never got it right. Now Obama takes time to consider the issue presented by a bumbling terrorist and MMcFM would have us panic. It’s a surrendeRepublican trait to cower.

  • Bill Adkins says:

    Oops – I know Napolitano is female, it’s just that I’ve always quoted the Peter Principle with a ‘his’ term.

  • StewartIII StewartIII says:

    She Cannot Be SURE?!
    ***
    Hot Air Poll: “The system worked”? Update: Rep. King votes … no
    http://hotair.com/archives/2009/12/27/poll-the-system-worked/

  • RazorsEdge RazorsEdge says:

    TC,

    Maybe you should have kept your gunpowder dry until after Napolitano’s appearance on CNN. You know where Napolitano stated to CNN to assure the public that air environment safe:

    Napolitano: that {Nigerian Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab} ‘was 1 individual literally of thousands that fly and thousands of flights every year’.

    You know, like 1 bomb attempt out of thousands of flghts pretty good odds. CNN mentions back to Napolitano “it only takes 1″ as if to say to Napolitano, don’t use that line any more because comes off tone deaf or the press will eat you alive for that comment and if I were you (Napolitano) I would think up a rational follow up to that 1 in thousands comment for tomorrow. You’ll need it.

    This is where the media plays a very valuable role in pushing government and making more public the policies and procedures such as “ties list”, screening, no-fly etc.

  • TfT TfT says:

    So, there is breaking news that yet another incident is ongoing at Detroit airport. CNN is covering it, FNC is in rerun, and MSNBC is well…..not a news organization.

    Ed Henry is spinning like a top for Obama — he is in the know, on the phone, taking a Presidential tone, acting like a leader, blah, blah, blah. He is also covering for Napolitano saying she is studying this new event and hasn’t said anything because they don’t want to alarm the public, yet there is CNN showing this new incident, with luggage spread all over the runway (for inspection purposes presumably), but no one from the WH or DHS is saying anything because no one knows what happened.

    NWA Flight 253 from Amsterdam requested emergency landing due to unruly passenger. Same airline, same flight number from Christmas day. Same scenario — someone spent a long time in the restroom, then became disruptive.

    Are these trial runs given Obama’s decision to move GITMO prisoners to US Soil?

  • BJL411 BJL411 says:

    Doesn’t matter what the US gov would have said on this, Repugs hate America and have always put party partisanship wayyyy ahead of Country.

    People have to accept some facts. At the end of the day, your % of getting killed in a car, by a car or stung by a bee are much higher than being killed in an airplane which have over 1 million flights per day.

    At the end of the day, unless we choose to strip search and body cavity search every human being who takes a plane, there is no freaking way we can ever be 100% safe.

    (If) there are 1 million people on the no-fly list (guessing a number here), then we can assume there are 2 million on the “watch list”.. and then there are 3 million on the “kinda keep an eye on them list”.. and so forth.

    This kid was way down the list.

    What needs to be investigated is (if) the father did report his son’s behavior to the Embassy in his country, then it is at THAT local we need to track back to see why that info wasn’t reviewed, sent on to the appropriate authorites, etc.

    Now here we are today with another so called “incident” which so far has turned out to be a guy who spent an hour in the bathroom, airplane crew questioned him, then he got verbally abusive. Now they are making a mountain out of a mole hill out of this and have so far found NOTHING.

    Our country has lost it’s f’king mind.

  • BJL411 BJL411 says:

    StewartIII says:
    December 27, 2009 at 1:40 pm
    She Cannot Be SURE?!
    ***
    Hot Air Poll: “The system worked”? Update: Rep. King votes … no
    http://hotair.com/archives/2009/12/27/poll-the-system-worked/

    HOT AIR ? LOL AND KING? LOL – KEEP GETTING YOUR TALKING POINTS FROM THE LUNATIC FRINGE RIGHT WING AND YOU’LL NEVER TRULY LEARN ANYTHING IMPORTANT.

  • disgusted disgusted says:

    Who?.?.?, besides herself – is she kidding?
    Some years ago, when the “in-thing” was to go to Havana – SAHSA (Stay At Home – Stay Alive) – NEVER had, even, an ‘attempted’ sky-jacking! The pilots were AF – and they were armed!

  • Tater Salad Tater Salad says:

    Passengers to Napolitano……….”What world are you living?” If that is a working system and you have to depend on the passengers to bring a plane in safe, you need to see a shrink”!

  • ImNotBlue ImNotBlue says:

    This is the type of thing that makes people furious. The system did NOT work properly… if it did, the guy would have never got on the plane.

    They got lucky… very very lucky. And when they did (the passengers, that is) they reacted the way they needed to, and were able to save lives. THEY are the only part of this “system” that worked correctly.

    As has been said, who does she think she’s fooling?

  • dhg dhg says:

    Yeah what kind of system works only because the bomb broke?Napolitano needs to go,should never have been hired.The reviews now being called for by our fearless leader should have been done before this happened not after or maybe never at all because it should have been done right the first time.But that’s ok just wait the system will get plenty of chances to be fixed once we have terrorists in Illinois and trials in NYC.

  • Chuck Steele says:

    Well ImnotBlue, she certainly seems to have BJL411 sold.
    That is why I love the car business. There are always people like BJL411 that are dumb enough to buy anything.
    But we will give Napolitano credit for having the wisdom to put Jasper on that airplane, a man with the will to survive and the courage to fight. If she hadn’t put him on that plane, God only knows what would/could have happened over Michigan. I’m going to nominate her for a Nobel Prize.

  • dhg dhg says:

    You can’t nominate her for the nobel prize,she doesn’t have any possible potential you never know it just might happen stuff to qualify her for it.

    And the passengers are not the only lucky ones,had the attack been successful the fortunes of many in DC would have forever changed.

  • puck30 puck30 says:

    Worked like clockwork…….

    This guy was on somebody’s list. He got through one, maybe two screenings. And in the end it was the passengers and flight crew that took this Terrorist down.

    Worked like clockwork……

    I think Janet should get that clock checked.

  • donabello donabello says:

    “which is a lot like bragging about how well Trojans work after your girlfriend is pregnant”

    I’d say “it is a lot like bragging about how well Trojans work after your girlfriend has had an abortion”.

  • m m says:

    Wow, all of you are whining about nothing. She clearly said the “clockwork” was post the attempt – that our government local, state and federal reaction to something like this is in great shape.

  • If you would like to comment, please login or register:

    » Login » Register

    » Or connect with your Facebook account:

    CNN’s John King, USA Premieres On Web With Rehearsal Show

    video

    There are two very distinct things to note about the way CNN has introduced the upcoming 7pmET show John King, USA to its audience - the show itself and the way it happened. John King hosted a trial run of the program today on CNN.com/live, which gave a sneak peek at what the show will be, but also gave viewers a chance to give their take on the first look.

    Is Meet the Press Trying to Diversify its Panels?: An Update

    A few weeks ago, Mediaite reported that Meet the Press has pledged to diversify its panels of guests and commentators. So how are they doing? Well, the show has gone four weeks in a row where African American men were featured on the show. This week's show will actually go one better: an African American guest and an African American journalist on the roundtable.



    © 2010 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | Dan Abrams, Founder | Hosting by Datagram | RSS