MSNBC Panel Explodes As ‘Gun Owner’ S.E. Cupp Battles Gun Control Advocate


MSNBC’s Now with Alex Wagner’s panel delved into gun control issues on Thursday which set off a heated yelling match between New York Daily News columnist S.E. Cupp and Dan Gross, President of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence.

RELATED: Young Turks Co-Host Says SE Cupp Would Be Proud Of Pretty Woman Prostitute

The panel became tense when Wagner opened with a discussion about proposed New York State legislation that would encode shell casings on bullets to more easily track those guns used in crimes. Major gun lobbies have opposed the legislation and at least one gun maker is threatening to pull their operation from New York if the bill passes.

Cupp, who describes herself as a gun owner, called the legislation “silly.”

“The idea is you track the bullet or the shell casing back to the gun and then you track the gun back to the owner because, ostensibly, the owner has registered his gun. Most criminals don’t do that,” said Cupp.

She said that most crimes are committed by those who have unregistered weapons while registered gun owners use their guns legally. Furthermore, the legislation would increase the manufacturing costs on gun makers which would be passed on to the legal gun consumer.

The debate quickly became heated when Gross challenged Cupp’s invoking costs. “At what cost is the savior of human lives,” asked Gross.

Crosstalk ensued until Gross asserted that this law has nothing to do with “gun control” and does not prevent gun purchasing. “This does not prevent anybody buying or selling a gun,” said Gross. “How can you call it gun control?”

Cupp became frustrated with what she described as the “hysteria” that surrounds guns and gun owners when there is high profile gun violence in the news.

“This is an industry that at all costs wants to protect its profits and it does so at the expense of human lives,” said Gross of the gun lobby.

“No, it wants to protect the Second Amendment which is under assault,” Cupp responded.

“That’s extremist rhetoric,” Gross replied. He called resistance to the law “anti-government paranoia.”

Wagner lamented that gun owners are too rigid in their resistance to laws that are designed to prevent gun violence. Cupp agreed, and said that both sides of the issue contribute to the hysteria surrounding the debate about gun ownership.

“I don’t accept that,” said Gross, interrupting Cupp as she attempted to make an equivalency between supporters and opponents of gun control legislation.

“Well, that’s okay,” said Cupp. She said that gun violence always prompts a conversation about the banning of fire arms.

Gross strongly objected to that suggestion. “Show me one word that’s ever come out of my mouth …”

“I don’t follow everything you say,” Cupp replied.

Watch the segment below via MSNBC:

Follow Noah Rothman on Twitter

Have a tip we should know?

Filed Under:

An experienced broadcaster and columnist, Noah Rothman has been providing political opinion and analysis to a variety of media outlets since 2010. His work has appeared in a number of political opinion journals, and he has shared his insights with television and radio personalities across the country.