MS NOW’s Jen Psaki Calls BS On ‘Disgusting and Ridiculous’ Trump Claims With Breakdown Of Stunning New ICE Shooting Video
MS NOW host and former Biden White House press secretary Jen Psaki called BS on President Donald Trump and his allies over their “disgusting and ridiculous” claim that the woman slain in Minneapolis was a “domestic terrorist” by examining new video of the incident.
On Friday’s edition of MS NOW’s The Briefing with Jen Psaki, the host opened her show with a detailed breakdown of the stunning new video of the killing of Renee Good by an ICE agent named Jonathan Ross.
Psaki went through the video that the right “seized on” and argued it refutes the “disgusting and ridiculous” blizzard of attacks from Trump and his officials:
JEN PSAKI, MS NOW HOST: Today, a right-wing outlet was the first to obtain and publish that video, which MS Now has now acquired as well. It is yet another angle of Wednesday morning’s shooting, and this time the video is from the perspective of a phone held by the shooter himself.
And the right has quickly jumped on this new footage. I mean, they are all over it, claiming it somehow vindicates the ICE agent responsible for killing Renee Nicole Good earlier this week. They claim that because the shooter appears to fumble his camera, and because you can hear a loud noise, that this video must be evidence that Renee Good ran over or hit the agent with her car. That is what they have been blasting everywhere.
But if you look at all of the evidence we have seen so far, that does not appear to be the case. Because so many people were filming this incident when it happened, we have a lot of footage that captured the scene from very different angles. And while I’m not a crime scene expert by any means, I certainly don’t claim to be one, but when you put them all together, which we’ve tried to do here, the picture of what happened on Wednesday morning gets clearer.
Now, DHS has said that the reason there was such a large ICE presence on that block to begin with was that an ICE vehicle had gotten stuck in the snow, and other ICE vehicles had arrived to help get it out. Residents, seeing the large ICE presence, then began blowing whistles, you can hear them right there, to warn that ICE was there. And they also started to film. That’s how we get a lot of this footage.
So today’s new video shows the shooter filming with his phone as he walks around Renee Nicole Good’s maroon SUV. Good then tells the agent, that’s fine, dude, I’m not mad at you.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
RENEE NICOLE GOOD, KILLED BY ICE: That’s fine, dude, I’m not mad at you.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: OK. You then see Good pull forward slightly, you can see it on your screen, and gesture for a vehicle to go around and pass her, which it does. From here, two things happen on opposite sides of the car simultaneously. The shooter continues circling the car. In the video on the left, you can see him filming the person who appears to be Good’s wife, as she films him and shouts at the officer. Now in the video on the right, on the other side of the car, two more federal agents get out of this silver pickup truck and approach Good’s car.
If you listen carefully, you can hear Good telling the agents to go around.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
GOOD: Go around.
ICE AGENT: Get out of the car! Get out of the car!
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: OK. After Good tells the agents to go around, they then told her, you could just hear that, to get the F out of the car. Good then backs her car up away from the agents, apparently to leave. And today’s new video shows her hands turning the steering wheel, clearly pointing the car in the opposite direction as the — as the agents before she proceeds to drive forward, of course. And at that same point in the wider video, you can see that her wheels are already turned away from the agents as she begins to move forward.
OK. So that brings us to the piece of this new video the right has absolutely latched onto, a moment of impact of some kind, in which the shooter’s camera becomes unstable and shaky. And this is what many on the right say is evidence that the car hit the officer. So let’s look at that moment on its own.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
ICE AGENT: Get out of the car.
(CROSSTALK)
ICE AGENT SHOOTER: Whoa!
(GUNSHOTS)
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: So the right has seized on those five seconds, five seconds where you can’t see much because the officer kind of fumbles his phone, to say that the car must have hit the agent who shot Good. They are claiming that that video vindicates the agent for firing those shots. But if you sync up that video with the other angle of that same moment, you can see that the car does not appear to run the agent over. In fact, the agent’s feet are positioned away from the car. And as I mentioned, the car is already headed in the opposite direction.
Now, let’s just take a moment to watch that side by side at full speed, because a lot is happening at once during the course of only about three seconds.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
ICE AGENT: Get out of the car.
(CROSSTALK)
ICE AGENT SHOOTER: Whoa!
(GUNSHOTS)
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: It happens very fast, three seconds, and it’s obviously hard to catch everything that’s going on. But you may notice that the moment that many on the right have attributed to the car hitting the agent, that moment occurs at virtually the same time he fires his first shot and at the very same time he fumbles his phone, which appears to be pressed up against his body.
Now both of those things happen almost simultaneously. So between the sound of the phone’s microphone potentially rubbing against the agent’s clothes and the muffled sound of the first gunshot, it’s hard to say what we are actually hearing. In other words, the sound that the right has seized upon could very well be the sound of his phone against his body combined with the sound of that first gunshot. Also, I can’t imagine that federal agents would be encouraged to use their cell phones while on duty, especially if they really thought that they were facing a life-threatening situation.
Today’s new video also reveals something that was said in the seconds after the shooting, and it involves some expletives. So if you have kids around and you want to hit mute for a second, this is — this is your moment. I mean, we cannot say for certain if it is the shooter or another agent or just a bystander, but about three seconds after the shots are fired, you can hear this in the shooter’s video.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
(GUNSHOTS)
UNIDENTIFIED: Fucking bitch.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: After he shot at her three times, after Good’s car crashes into another car down the block, the agents do not appear to rush to her aid. They do not appear to be in any rush at all. The shooter eventually approaches the car and then slowly walks back to his fellow agents and tells them to call 911.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED: What did you do? You! Shame! Shame! Shame!
ICE AGENT SHOOTER: Hey, call 911!
UNIDENTIFIED: Shame! Shame! Shame!
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: Now later, someone who identifies himself as a doctor offers to help, but the federal agents on the scene turn him away.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED: Can I go check a pulse?
ICE AGENT: No! Back up, now!
UNIDENTIFIED: I’m a physician!
ICE AGENT: I don’t care.
ICE AGENT: Listen, we understand. We’ve got EMS coming, I get it, just give us a second. We have medics on-scene. We have our own medics.
UNIDENTIFIED: Where are they? Where are they?
(END VIDEO CLIP)
PSAKI: We have medics on the scene. That was one of the last things you heard one of the officers say. Well, it ultimately took more than six minutes before emergency medical personnel arrived. So medics were not, in fact, on the scene.
Also, we at MS Now have not independently confirmed this, but The New York Times reports that several agents, including the shooter, then got in their vehicles and drove away, leaving an active crime scene, leaving a 37-year-old mother of three that one of their officers had shot three times.
Renee Nicole Good told those officers, I’m not mad at you. That’s the woman the Trump administration called a domestic terrorist. That’s the woman whose killing Vice President J.D. Vance called a tragedy of her own making. And all this new video does is make clear that those claims are just as disgusting and ridiculous as they were before we saw this new video. She said, I’m not mad at you. And 25 seconds after she uttered those words, she was shot.
Watch above via MS NOW’s The Briefing with Jen Psaki.
Comments
↓ Scroll down for comments ↓