‘Amazing Own Goal’: DC Press ‘Mindblown’ By Team Trump Thinking Leaked Letter Would Damage Biden and Help Trump

Doug Mills / Anna Moneymaker, Getty Images
Political journalists were stunned by Team Trump’s apparent leak of a letter they thought would help former President Donald Trump and damage President Joe Biden — but which did the opposite.
Former Fox News contributor and pro-Trump founder of “Just the News” John Solomon published what he said were damning documents about the search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago resort home, which is part of an investigation of Trump for crimes involving the Espionage Act.
Solomon wrote that memos and letters show “the Biden White House worked directly with the Justice Department and National Archives to instigate the criminal probe into alleged mishandling of documents, allowing the FBI to review evidence retrieved from Mar-a-Lago this spring and eliminating the 45th president’s claims to executive privilege.”
But leading Washington, DC journalists were baffled by the leak, which they say had the opposite effect of showing that Biden deferred to independent agencies, that Trump and his team were given plenty of opportunities to comply but drew out the process, that the seized materials in question are “hair on fire” serious, and otherwise picking it apart.
Leading the pack was New York Times correspondent and CNN analyst Maggie Haberman, who wrote:
Confusing to assess how this letter helps Trump, which whoever gave it to Solomon seemed to think it would. Among other things, it confirms our reporting that SAP material – highly restricted information – was part of what was returned from MAL.
There were at least 700 pages of classified material given to NARA in the 15 boxes, per letter to Corcoran.
NARA letter also confirms that Trump team was delaying the process, and given extensions. And it makes clear that there’s no presidential privilege in a case like this.
Confusing to assess how this letter helps Trump, which whoever gave it to Solomon seemed to think it would. Among other things, it confirms our reporting that SAP material – highly restricted information – was part of what was returned from MAL https://t.co/ZaFDNPD5Bg
— Maggie Haberman (@maggieNYT) August 23, 2022
NARA letter also confirms that Trump team was delaying the process, and given extensions. And it makes clear that there’s no presidential privilege in a case like this https://t.co/ZaFDNPD5Bg
— Maggie Haberman (@maggieNYT) August 23, 2022
Lachlan Markay of Axios called it an “Amazing own goal by Team Trump.”
“They released this letter thinking it’d show political meddling by Biden. In fact, it shows the opposite—he delegated exec privilege decisions—while also revealing new info on highly sensitive material in Trump’s possession,” he wrote.
Amazing own goal by Team Trump. They released this letter thinking it’d show political meddling by Biden. In fact, it shows the opposite—he delegated exec privilege decisions—while also revealing new info on highly sensitive material in Trump’s possession https://t.co/QZ1u01AsBT
— Lachlan Markay (@lachlan) August 23, 2022
CBS News Radio White House correspondent Steve Portnoy listed the many ways Solomon’s scoop undercut Trump in a Twitter thread:
Via @costareports, CBS News has confirmed the text of a May 10th letter the acting Archivist of the US sent to Trump’s legal team, first posted by John Solomon last night.
It contains several important revelations…
1) NARA determined that “Special Access Program” material was in the 15 boxes turned over by Trump last winter. That’s more secret than TS/SCI.
2) There was a back-and-forth on the question of “protective” executive privilege between Trump, NARA and the Biden WH in the spring.
3) According to the archivist, Biden WH determined that it would allow NARA to say whether any material at Mar-a-Lago might be covered by exec privilege.
4) Trump lawyers asked NARA to hold off on transferring the “15 boxes” to the FBI for a nat sec damage assessment.
5) NARA and DOJ jointly determined that request should be denied.
6) The letter establishes that Biden administration believes firmly that there is no executive privilege that Trump could assert here, and that it’s not even close.
Fox News White House correspondent Jacqui Heinrich‘s takeaway was not favorable to Trump:
Documents recovered at Mar-a-Lago were among government’s most classified, letter shows – POLITICO https://t.co/1pd3bPMXc6
— Jacqui Heinrich (@JacquiHeinrich) August 23, 2022
Many other journos, analysts and experts weighed in as well:
Ironically, Trump’s media guy shows how NARA was bending over backwards for Trump before it finally gave the FBI access to the classified records.
Full text of National Archives letter to Trump on classified documents https://t.co/DYfbBjDA90 via @JustTheNews
— Bradley P. Moss (@BradMossEsq) August 23, 2022
May 10 letter from Archives to Trump explains why Trump, a former executive, has no executive privilege claim against current executive. It also debunks claim that he’s been cooperative with requests to return documents. If anything, they’ve been too soft. https://t.co/TZrIit61xY
— Barb McQuade (@BarbMcQuade) August 23, 2022
Furthermore, Trump’s attorneys ignore that they were told by NARA back in May that there was no precedent for “an assertion of executive privilege by a former President against an incumbent President.” https://t.co/X7iGdfTQzr https://t.co/GwFQGi00kZ
— Mark Remillard (@MarkJRemillard) August 23, 2022
“According to NARA, among the materials in the boxes are over 100 documents with classification markings, comprising more than 700 pages. Some include the highest levels of classification, including Special Access Program (SAP) materials.” https://t.co/6ltre62vZq
— Jake Tapper (@jaketapper) August 23, 2022
“NARA identified items marked as classified national security information, up to the level of Top Secret and including Sensitive Compartmented Information and Special Access Program materials.” https://t.co/7QsW8Ca4oc
— Rick Klein (@rickklein) August 23, 2022
Trump’s strategy, as Haberman has alluded to elsewhere, has included a heavy focus on capitalizing on the rallying effect the raid has had with his followers, who may be willing to overlook facts in favor of the attractive premise of Solomon’s reporting.