1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough

Gretchen Carlson Questions Obama’s References To God; Newt Gingrich Defends

video
» 35 comments

Much has already been written about the positives and negatives of President Obama’s addressing the nation last night, but one topic that is still getting a strong reaction from both sides of the political divide? The President’s references and appeal to God (and prayer) as he ended the speech. In fact, this issue came up this very morning on Fox and Friends, and the President’s religion got an unlikely supporter: former GOP Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich.

Some on the left have criticized him, claiming that “prayer is not a solution” while some on the right (Gretchen Carlson) have claimed it’s disingenuous for someone who does not regularly attend church to reference God.

A regular contributor to Fox News, Gingrich was a guest on Fox and Friends to discuss a number of political topics of the day, but the discussion of Obama and God was most interesting, particularly given that Gingrich has historically been one of Obama’s most vocal critics on a myriad of issues. A rough transcript precedes the video clip below:

Kilmeade: Now let’s talk about something else, some content in the speech that you might have found surprising. Listen to president obama and his references to God.

Obama: It is not the last crisis America will face. this nation has known hard times before and we will surely know them again. what sees us through, what has always seen us through is our strength, our resilience, and our unyielding faith that something better awaits us if we summon the courage to reach for it. tonight we pray for that courage. we pray for the people of the gulf. we pray that a hand may guide us through the storm towards a brighter day.

Doocy: Mr. Speaker, what do you think of that?

Gingrich: Well, I hope he means it. Llook, I’m not going to resent any time a president of the United States calls on God. I think it’s good. I think it was good when Franklin D. Roosevelt led the country in a 6 1/2 minute prayer on D-Day which some 900 radio stations replayed this year. I think it is good to recognize that our rights come from our Creator. And I’m delighted that the president — I’m sad it took a crisis of this scale, but I’m delighted that the President has recognized that we, in fact, all are subordinate to a larger God and that we need to seek guidance from that God.

Gretchen: Did you find it disingenuous? People are analyzing that this morning as saying it was disingenuous coming from a President who does not go to church on a regular basis.

Gingrich: Look, let me say, in my new book “”So take America,”" I reprint the entire 12 step program from Alcoholics Anonymous. Six of the 12 steps involve a higher authority. I’m happy for any President of the United States to find a moment to turn to God, to seek guidance and I think it’s important for us to be a little generous at a moment like this. If he’s prepared to publicly recognize God, maybe we should encourage him to do it more often.

Follow us on Twitter.

Sign up for Mediaite's daily newsletter.

Email Twitter Facebook Digg Reddit Stumble Upon Yahoo Buzz LinkedIn Tumblr Delicious
  • paulmdoro

    On this issue I think Carlson is being quite obtuse and foolish. Faith and spirituality have nothing to do with how often one attends church. I have conservative relatives who haven’t been to church in decades yet reference God almost daily.

  • http://TheDividedStatesBlog.com Publius219

    I’d take it further and say that on most any issue Carlson is quite obtuse and foolish. But we know she was hired solely for her journalistic qualifications, and not because of her looks or religious/political viewpoints. Err…What?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dave-Noland/1343446359 Dave Noland

    Some people? You mean FOX! Gretchen I Promise GOd doesn’t love you.

  • JohnSimpson

    Let everyone chose for themselves how they wish to believe in God or not to.

    God existed long before churches did.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Phil-Bourekas/1538058627 Phil Bourekas

    There appears to be little reason to believe Obama is religious. Pointing to church attendance is a simple, but not the only, indicator of that.

    Obama feels that religion is the hallmark of the desparate and failing. Specifically, he has said “they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations”–thereby equating religion to guns, antipathy, anti-immigration, perhaps even racism (in the context of the original speech).

    That said, it’s ok for him to exhort others to the means that comfort them. Just don’t pretend that Obama does this naturally.

  • The_Reasonable_Lib

    Every time this woman opens her mouth something stupid comes out of it. I can’t believe that somebody with her credentials would degrade herself to such a level. Then again, I guess this is the American dream in action.

  • MichelleF

    I have no problem with it, but I do find it a little contradictary, since he sat in a church where GD America was used. Oh i forgot, he didn’t hear that. I shutter to think what those who go to that church are praying for.

  • paulmdoro

    Michelle there are pastors who have called Obama the Antichrist and prayed for his death, so I shudder to think what those people are praying about.

  • Rogue-Comic

    Damn, Gretchen gets more hate (and coverage at mediate) for uttering one sentence than drug dealers who kill ranchers.

    Religion can be a unifying force, but it can also be the catalyst for a great divide. With all due respect to the President and the former speaker, prayer isn’t going to solve anything.

    What Obama really needs to do is suck it up and put in a call to Palin and unleash her on BP, and Palin needs to suck it up and work with Obama in reigning in a common enemy.

  • MichelleF

    Me to Paul, that doesn’t happen in my church.

  • Level Headed American

    I think Gretchen spent too much time in the sun on her vacation.

  • paulmdoro

    Most of us have no idea what goes on in the churches of others, and casting judgment upon them from the outside is very easy. It isn’t always a black and white issue.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Terry-Canaan/666670819 Terry Canaan

    This is idiotic. Bush only saw the inside of a church when he went to weddings and funerals and he wouldn’t shut up about God. Where were you then, Gretchen?

    But worse, what the morons at Fox & Friends take away as the big news story from a presidential address about energy and the environment is whether he should talk about God? Really?

    I’m starting to wonder if F&F isn’t actively trying to take the title of “Most Idiotic TV Show in American History” away from “Tim and Eric Awesome Show.” Because really, they’re doing WAY too good a job of that for it to be mere coincidence.

  • Rogue-Comic

    I’m starting to wonder if people really think for themselves anymore, or they simply accept a headline on a tabloid web site as gospel and go off accordingly.

  • Big_F-ing_Deal

    Religion is a competition where you keep score by how many times you go to Church.

    And Gretchen is winning!

  • Rogue-Comic

    Amazing how one sentence can inspire so many . . .

  • ex political-media hack

    Religion is a competition where you keep score by how many times you can mention God in the last sentences of a natl televised press conference. (was it 5 or 6?)

  • paulmdoro

    So I guess how one feels about a president saying “God” depends on whether or not they voted for said president.

  • Rogue-Comic

    Perspective can be ironic . . .

  • MichelleF

    paulmdoro says:
    June 16, 2010 at 3:24 pm
    Most of us have no idea what goes on in the churches of others, and casting judgment upon them from the outside is very easy. It isn’t always a black and white issue.

    Feel free to bring a camera into my church at any time. I wouldn’t be ashamed of anything that is said. Unfortuantely, Rev Wright likes to tape his “sermons”, so you can’t really say we don’t know what goes on in there.

  • paulmdoro

    That’s great Michelle. I am very happy for you and your church. That is one church out of how many in America?

  • Big_F-ing_Deal

    “Religion is a competition where you keep score by how many times you can mention God in the last sentences of a natl televised press conference. (was it 5 or 6?)”

    Who knows. No one gives a shit enough to count except for you righties.

    Hey, aren’t you the one who said the story of Representative Bob Etheridge pushing a student was not going away and was gonna blow up in 3 days and be HUGE?

    Well, it’s been 3 days! lolol

  • MichelleF

    Paul, My point is that I think it’s appropriate and fair to comment on what is said in Rev Wright’s church, since it’s on video.

  • paulmdoro

    How many sermons are on video? How many have you watched? Obviously he said hateful, awful things, but he has been there over 20 years right? My mother was totally appalled and disgusted by certain things some Catholic priests said at a church she attended for some 30 years, but she didn’t leave (my parents moved out of town recently) the church.

  • MichelleF

    Let’s just say I’ve watched enough to be outraged that our sitting president sat and listened to them.

  • notsofast

    Is this Obama clinging to his religion?

  • redleaf

    I’ve never watched Fox and Friends, but I read about it constantly on this site.
    Based on what I read here, Fox and Friends is a piece of work.
    Slyly presented anti-liberal daytime talk to indoctrinate a female viewership to the FNC philosophy.
    Sounds pretty easy to see through.
    But again, I haven’t watched the show.

  • notsofast

    But again, I haven’t watched the show.”

    Your comments prove just that.

  • redleaf

    God, I hate this site.
    See, I was honest enough to caveat my comments by TWICE saying, “I haven’t watched the show” and my opinions are based on what I read on mediaite.

    How many opinions here are blindly vomited out by people who just say crap without being honest enough to note their biases or conflicts? Then again, if all news outlets noted their own biases and conflicts, the political discourse in America would be more honest, less vitriolic and less based on false or concocted information.

    But we can’t have that now, can we? Instead, we get useless snark like the comments from notsofast.

  • MichelleF

    I’ve never watched Fox and Friends, but I read about it constantly on this site.
    Based on what I read here, Fox and Friends is a piece of work.

    Surprising you would come to that conclusion, based only on what is “reported” on this site.

  • Rogue-Comic

    “How many opinions here are blindly vomited out by people who just say crap without being honest enough to note their biases or conflicts?”
    _______________________________________________________

    Too many.

    And this comment marks the 30th one of its source based on one sentence uttered by a talk show host.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Kam-Fet/572005492 Kam Fet

    OOOPS, Newt didn’t follow the script.

  • paulmdoro

    How many is enough Michelle? Two? Five? How many hours did it comprise? And how do you know what he talked about with the president in attendance? Were you there? Should my mother have left her church after some priests made remarks that disgusted and appalled her? Or for many people is it not that simple, because their church has come to mean something to them, it’s vital to their life, a community they care about and depend on?

  • http://none pyrope

    -0bama = 24k phony

  • Integr8d

    That dude was just on there to plug his book. That was it.

© 2012 Mediaite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Self-Serve Advertising | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Power Grid FAQ | Contact | Archives | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram